Residents of Sydney are voicing their strong opinions regarding a Christmas tree installation at Martin Place. This festive centerpiece stands 14.5 meters tall and is located outside 25 Martin Place, historically known as the MLC Centre. Created by the luxury fashion brand Dolce & Gabbana, the tree has become a focal point for controversy due to its messaging.
Controversy Over Messaging
Instead of the traditional greeting “Merry Christmas,” the tree features phrases like “Happy Holidays,” “Warm Wishes,” and “Season’s Greetings.” This change has sparked outrage among some Australians who believe it undermines the significance of Christmas. Political commentator Matthew Camenzuli criticized the messaging on social media, labeling it “offensive” and calling it an example of excessive political correctness.
Public Reactions
Camenzuli emphasized, “It’s Merry Christmas! Anything less is offensive to Christians, and Australia is a Christian country.” Although statistics from the 2021 census indicate that 43.9% of Australians identify as Christian, Australia is officially a secular nation.
- 43.9% of Australians identify as Christian (2021 census)
- Christmas tree height: 14.5 meters
Overall, many social media users echoed his sentiment, describing the tree as “too woke” and accusing Dolce & Gabbana of diluting traditions for the sake of inclusivity. A frequent criticism centered on the use of “Happy Holidays,” which some claimed sounded more American than Australian.
To gauge public sentiment, I visited Martin Place and spoke to several locals. One young tradesman expressed, “I think we should say Merry Christmas; it’s the season of Christ.” A woman added, “It’s sad that ‘Merry Christmas’ is being phased out. It’s a tradition.” She also questioned the need for inclusive language, stating, “If you’re not celebrating Christmas, what are you celebrating?”
Variety of Opinions
Conversely, not all feedback was critical of the tree’s message. A woman in a festive shirt voiced her support for inclusivity, saying, “I appreciate everything Sydney does to make people feel included.” Another passerby commented, “For most people, it’s just about family and friends. Why not have ‘Happy Holidays’ instead of just Christmas?”
Despite varying opinions on the matter, one thing is certain: the installation has prompted a lively debate among Sydney residents. As the festive season approaches, it remains to be seen how Christmas traditions will continue to evolve in Australia.
Both El-Balad and Dolce & Gabbana have been approached for comments regarding the public discourse surrounding the tree.
