When Kaiden Guhle returns from injury, the Montreal Canadiens face a compelling decision regarding their defensive lineup. The emergence of capable young defencemen has created a situation where the team must choose between Arber Xhekaj and Jayden Struble for the sixth defensive spot.
The Canadiens’ Defensive Landscape
The Canadiens entered the 2025-26 season with a solid defensive rotation. Key players included:
- Mike Matheson
- Noah Dobson
- Kaiden Guhle
- Lane Hutson
Xhekaj began the season on the third defensive pairing, with Struble watching from the press box. This choice was justified by Xhekaj’s size and toughness. He provided a physical edge, an attribute valuable for a developing team.
Struble’s Opportunity
However, with Guhle sidelined due to injury, Struble capitalized on this opportunity. He has averaged over 15 minutes of ice time per game and made a significant impact. In 10 games, he recorded three assists along with a plus-1 rating.
Struble’s improved puck management and transition skating have contributed positively to the Canadiens’ play. His ability to join the offense without compromising defensive responsibilities has been notable.
Xhekaj’s Contributions
Contrastingly, Xhekaj’s performance has been a bit uneven. In 13 games, he has only one assist and a minus-4 rating. His physical play is still an asset; however, it often comes with positioning drawbacks and penalties. The Canadiens emphasize controlled aggression, a facet where Struble currently excels.
Considerations for Selection
Struble offers versatile skills. He can play on both sides of the ice, kill penalties, and manage the puck effectively. While Xhekaj brings raw power, Struble compensates with better decision-making and skating ability. Nonetheless, Xhekaj maintains a crucial role in controlling physical play during matchups against heavier teams like the Boston Bruins and Toronto Maple Leafs.
Benefits of Having Depth
This dilemma underscores a positive trend for the Canadiens’ defensive strategy. A few years back, the team struggled with a lack of depth on defense. Now, with players like Matheson, Carrier, Hutson, and Dobson securing top roles, the competition for the sixth spot is a sign of growth.
Such competition fosters improvement and allows head coach Martin St. Louis to tailor the lineup based on opponents. Xhekaj can provide physicality when needed, while Struble is preferred for speed and puck movement.
The Future of the Sixth Defenseman
As Guhle returns, keeping Struble in the lineup seems logical. His reliable, mistake-free play aligns well with the Canadiens’ fast-paced identity. Xhekaj remains a valuable seventh defenceman, always ready to step in and make contributions.
Overall, this situation exemplifies the Canadiens’ strengthening defensive depth. The team’s improved structure is evident as goals-against averages decrease and puck exits become more efficient. With Guhle’s recovery and ongoing development of players like Hutson, Montreal’s defense could soon become a top contender in the conference.
