Why Isn’t Trump’s Tariff Revenue Keeping the Government Open?

As the federal government remains shut down, hundreds of thousands of employees are either furloughed or working without pay. This impasse, caused by a lack of agreement between Republicans and Democrats over funding, has led to significant disruption in core government functions, including food and drug inspections.
Tariff Revenue Amidst Government Shutdown
Despite the shutdown, the government continues to collect record levels of tariff revenue. President Donald Trump has often touted these earnings, which have reached considerable heights. However, while the tariff collections are impressive, they fall short of covering the government’s expenses.
In September, the Treasury Department reported $31.7 billion in tariff revenue, contributing to an annual total of $190 billion, which represents a 160% increase compared to the same period the previous year. On the initial day of the shutdown, October 1, the government earned $315 million from tariffs.
Comparative Costs: Tariff Revenue vs. Federal Salaries
To put this into perspective, the daily compensation for approximately 750,000 furloughed federal workers is estimated at around $400 million, according to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO). While tariff revenue flows into the Treasury’s general fund—referred to as “America’s checkbook”—it remains largely unutilized during this period of fiscal uncertainty.
- Tariff revenue (September): $31.7 billion
- Total tariff revenue (2023): $190 billion
- Daily tariff collection (October 1): $315 million
- Estimated daily cost of federal salaries: $400 million
Although the administration has suggested that lawmakers could deploy tariff revenues to mitigate the shutdown’s impact, such measures have not gained significant traction. White House spokesperson Kush Desai emphasized that the solution lies in the Democrats passing a clean continuing resolution to reopen the government.
Economic Implications of Tariff Policies
The collection of tariffs has sparked ongoing debate among lawmakers. Many Democrats express concern that these tariffs result in higher prices for consumers. Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon, the leading Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, argued for repealing the trade taxes, asserting that they lock in elevated prices for Americans.
Wyden critiqued the notion that tariff revenue could serve as a viable solution to the shutdown, pointing out its marginal contribution to essential government services such as the military, national parks, and law enforcement. “Trump’s tariffs are the problem, not the solution,” he remarked, highlighting the urgency for sustainable funding strategies.
In conclusion, while tariff revenue may appear substantial, it pales in comparison to the broader financial requirements of running the federal government. The ongoing shutdown underscores the necessity for Congress to reach an agreement that ensures the continued functioning of essential services.