The Netflix series “House of Guinness” delves into the lives of the Guinness brewing family’s heirs during the late 1800s. However, it has generated mixed reactions, particularly among family members who feel the portrayal is overly dramatized and not entirely accurate.
Contention Around “House of Guinness”
Creator Steven Knight has acknowledged that much of the narrative in “House of Guinness” contains fabricated elements. He explained, “I had to take things that these family members did and use them as steppingstones,” indicating a blend of real-life events with fictional storytelling.
Family Responses and Criticism
Not all members of the Guinness family are supportive of the show. Molly Guinness, a great-great-granddaughter of Edward Guinness, expressed her displeasure in an op-ed for The Times of London. She described the characters as cliché representations of wealthy individuals, stating, “Every episode starts with the weaselly old Netflix disclaimer ‘This fiction is inspired by true stories.’”
Particularly controversial is the character Sean Rafferty, played by James Norton, who does not exist in the family’s history but serves as a fictional henchman. Molly criticized the portrayal of Arthur Guinness’s sexuality, which is primarily speculative.
Inspiration Behind the Series
The idea for the series originated with Ivana Lowell, a family member who conceived the project while watching “Downton Abbey.” In discussing her family, she remarked, “Our family is so much more interesting and eccentric.” Her 2010 memoir, “Why Not Say What Happened?”, also played a role in creating interest in the family’s story for television.
Future Plans for the Series
Despite the criticism, “House of Guinness” has succeeded in captivating viewers, leading to Netflix securing Steven Knight for additional seasons. Knight confirmed that production plans include seasons two, three, and potentially four, with the story expected to extend into the 1960s.
Key Takeaways
- Series Title: House of Guinness
- Creator: Steven Knight
- Inspired By: Ivana Lowell’s memoir
- Critical Response: Mixed reactions within the Guinness family
- Future Seasons: Confirmed for two additional seasons
As “House of Guinness” continues to unfold, it remains a topic of discussion regarding the balance between historical fact and creative liberty in storytelling.
