NHL Midseason Grades: Evaluating Every Team’s Performance

The NHL season is at the midpoint, allowing for an evaluation of all 32 teams’ performances. As teams have completed between 46 and 49 games, it’s the perfect time to assess their standings and objectives for the rest of the season. The analysis covers team grades, focusing on their current status, progress toward a championship, and potential future outlooks.
NHL Midseason Grades: Overview of Team Performances
Anaheim Ducks: C+
The Ducks initially showcased an exciting style of play, but have faced challenges. Their once-effective offense has struggled, leading to a nine-game losing streak. Opponents have adapted to their strategy, highlighting defensive vulnerabilities.
Boston Bruins: B+
The Bruins remain a playoff contender despite fading slightly. They have shown resilience after a poor previous season, buoyed by the return of goaltender Jeremy Swayman and several players exceeding expectations.
Buffalo Sabres: B
After a rocky start, the Sabres gained momentum with a 10-game winning streak. Under new general manager Jarmo Kekäläinen, the team has improved and is now positioned for a wild-card spot.
Calgary Flames: D
Expected to contend, the Flames have faltered significantly, struggling offensively and failing to excite their fan base. The team is now focused on rebuilding while ensuring their younger players gain experience.
Carolina Hurricanes: B+
The Hurricanes lead the Metropolitan Division despite facing injuries. They have identified promising goaltender Brandon Bussi and are beginning to recover key players from injury.
Chicago Blackhawks: B
Surprisingly competitive, the Blackhawks have benefited from standout performances, particularly from rookie Connor Bedard. The team remains in contention, showcasing improved structure and competitiveness.
Colorado Avalanche: A+
The Avalanche are on track for a record-breaking season, boasting a remarkable plus-79 goal differential. Their key players, including Nathan MacKinnon, lead numerous statistical categories, solidifying their dominance.
Columbus Blue Jackets: D
The Blue Jackets continue to struggle, currently sitting near the bottom of the standings after firing their coach. Their offensive and defensive issues have led to disappointing performances this season.
Dallas Stars: B+
The Stars are performing well despite a six-game losing streak that hindered their chase of the Avalanche. Their top players are having excellent seasons, positioning the team for a potential playoff run.
Detroit Red Wings: B+
Exceeding expectations, the Red Wings are competing for the Atlantic Division lead. Strong contributions from various players and solid goaltending have played a pivotal role in their success.
Edmonton Oilers: B+
Led by stars Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, the Oilers exhibit championship potential. However, they have struggled with depth and consistency, necessitating improvements in their supporting lines.
Florida Panthers: B
The Panthers have faced key injuries but remain competitive, showing resilience and an upward trajectory in playoff positioning despite a shaky start to the season.
Los Angeles Kings: D
The Kings’ performance has been underwhelming, with inadequate replacements for key players and a lack of improvement following previous season struggles. They maintain an average presence in a weak division.
Minnesota Wild: A
The Wild have transitioned from a disappointing start to one of the league’s top teams. Strong goaltending and star players have positioned them as legitimate contenders.
Montreal Canadiens: A
The Canadiens are surprising many this season, competing for the Atlantic Division lead with noteworthy contributions from their young roster.
Nashville Predators: C
After inconsistent early results, the Predators have found their form. Under coach Andrew Brunette, they are striving for playoff revival amid a rebuilding phase.
New Jersey Devils: D
After a solid start, the Devils have descended into mediocrity, struggling significantly with injuries and overall performance.
New York Islanders: B+
Despite some defensive concerns, the Islanders are exceeding expectations and showing progress under new management.
New York Rangers: F
The Rangers have a dismal record, sitting under .500. Persistent poor performances have led to discussions about the team’s future direction.
Ottawa Senators: D+
Despite underlying strong metrics, the Senators’ goaltending struggles have hindered their chances of playoff contention, leaving them in a difficult spot.
Philadelphia Flyers: B+
The Flyers have surprised many by remaining competitive, sparked by effective offseason additions and some standout performances.
Pittsburgh Penguins: A-
Defying expectations, the Penguins have fought for a playoff spot, though their inconsistent performances earlier in the season raise questions about their stability.
San Jose Sharks: A+
Significantly improved from last season, the Sharks are in a playoff position thanks to standout performances from rookie Macklin Celebrini.
Seattle Kraken: B
With strong goaltending backing them, the Kraken have remained competitive. Their transition into a strong defensive team highlights their growth this season.
St. Louis Blues: F
Struggling massively, the Blues have the lowest goal differential and are facing a dire outlook this season, well below initial expectations.
Tampa Bay Lightning: A-
With depth and resilience, the Lightning remain strong competitors despite injury challenges. Their core players have kept the team in contention.
Toronto Maple Leafs: C
The Maple Leafs have emerged from a tumultuous start, but their early struggles raise concerns about their playoff viability.
Winnipeg Jets: F
After a high-performing previous season, the Jets have plummeted to near the bottom of the standings, struggling with a lack of scoring and aging roster problems.
As the NHL season progresses, teams continue to adapt and assess their standings, gauging what their next steps should be in a highly competitive landscape.




