The future of the Toronto Maple Leafs roster for the 2026-27 season is uncertain, with no player guaranteed to return. Key players like Auston Matthews and William Nylander, along with others such as Morgan Rielly and Max Domi, could be on the move. As the offseason approaches, a comprehensive evaluation of each player’s future role on the team is essential.
Key Players and Their Potential Futures
Auston Matthews
Why he stays: Matthews enjoys playing in Toronto and wants to compete for a Stanley Cup.
Why he goes: If he loses faith in the team’s direction, he may seek other opportunities.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
William Nylander
Why he stays: He has a long-term contract and enjoys being part of the team.
Why he goes: If Matthews leaves, Nylander could follow suit as part of a rebuild.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
Max Domi
Why he stays: His current contract makes him challenging to move after an underwhelming season.
Why he goes: The thin free-agent market may prompt a trade for Domi.
Likeliest outcome: Goes
Matthew Knies
Why he stays: As a young talent, he remains a crucial part of the team’s future.
Why he goes: His value may attract trade offers for more immediate needs.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
John Tavares
Why he stays: Tavares wants to finish his career with the Maple Leafs and still contributes significantly.
Why he goes: A rebuilding phase could lead to a trade for a younger player.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
Defensive and Goalie Outlook
Morgan Rielly
Why he stays: He prefers to remain with the team and holds a no-movement clause.
Why he goes: The management assesses the need for a fresh start on defense.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
Jake McCabe
Why he stays: McCabe’s solid performance makes him a reliable defensive asset.
Why he goes: His trade value could be considered high if the team seeks changes.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
Joseph Woll
Why he stays: Woll has potential as a starting goalie and is under a favorable contract.
Why he goes: The emergence of Dennis Hildeby could complicate the goalie situation.
Likeliest outcome: Stays
Supporting Players Assessment
- Easton Cowan – Likeliest outcome: Stays. A young asset for the future.
- Calle Järnkrok – Likeliest outcome: Goes. Limited impact this season.
- Oliver Ekman-Larsson – Likeliest outcome: Goes. Aging player with trade potential.
- Nick Robertson – Likeliest outcome: Goes. Needs a contract, but has struggled.
As the offseason progresses, the Maple Leafs face pivotal decisions on their roster. Every move will shape the team’s direction, determining whether they pursue a retool or a complete rebuild. The outcomes of key players could define the 2026-27 season significantly.
