North Andover police officer Kelsey Fitzsimmons has been acquitted of assault with a dangerous weapon. The verdict came from Lawrence Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Karp after a bench trial that lasted under three days.
Kelsey Fitzsimmons Verdict Overview
The judge expressed reasonable doubt regarding the accusations against Fitzsimmons. She had been accused of pointing her firearm at fellow officer Pat Noonan during an incident at her home last summer. Noonan subsequently fired at Fitzsimmons, injuring her, while she claimed to have aimed the gun at herself.
Trial Details and Judgment
Judge Karp deliberated for less than two hours before delivering his verdict. Fitzsimmons opted for a bench trial, resulting in Karp ruling without a jury. According to the judge, both officers provided credible testimony, a point he found “unusual” and “somewhat perplexing.” He also highlighted that the case would have been clearer if the officers were equipped with body cameras.
- Trial Duration: Less than three days
- Deliberation Time: Under two hours
Kelsey Fitzsimmons’ Reaction
Outside the courtroom, Fitzsimmons shared her relief and emotional turmoil. She emphasized the hardships she faced, including being shot, spending 103 days in jail, and being separated from her son. “This is my first breath of fresh air, and I feel like I can breathe again,” she stated. Nonetheless, she affirmed her ongoing struggles and focus on reuniting with her child.
District Attorney’s Response
The Essex County District Attorney, Paul Tucker, voiced disagreement with the verdict. He commended the professionalism of the prosecution and acknowledged the inherent dangers police face, particularly during high-pressure situations like responding to restraining orders. Tucker insisted that the indictment was brought in good faith and backed by credible police testimonies and physical evidence.
Testimonies and Defense Arguments
During the trial, closing arguments presented contrasting narratives. The defense argued that Noonan had a motive to alter his account of the events due to an alleged excessive use of force. The prosecution, however, sought to prove that Fitzsimmons had lied under oath. They claimed Fitzsimmons had attempted to chamber a bullet and pointed the gun towards Noonan.
- Date of Incident: June 30, 2025
- Charges Against Fitzsimmons: Assault
- Injury: Collapsed lung from gunfire
Fitzsimmons testified that she did not aim the gun at Noonan but rather intended a self-harm act. Her attorneys contended that Noonan acted hastily without assessing the situation adequately. They referred to Fitzsimmons’ tragic circumstances, claiming that the day of the incident marked a deeply distressing moment in her life.
Aftermath and Continuing Issues
As the case concludes, questions remain about the protocols followed by law enforcement in such incidents. Fitzsimmons’ future in the police force is uncertain, as she focuses on healing and reconnecting with her child. The case has sparked discussions about the necessity of body cameras in policing, especially in volatile situations involving mental health crises.
If you or someone you know is experiencing emotional distress, please seek help through available resources such as the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline.
