Caleb Downs Predicts Smith and Tate May Surpass Jefferson, Chase as Top WR Duo

Ohio State’s wide receiver duo, Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate, is making headlines this season. Their impressive performance has drawn comparisons to another iconic pair, Justin Jefferson and Ja’Marr Chase, who played together at LSU.
Caleb Downs Weighs In
In a recent episode of his podcast, Downs 2 Business, Buckeyes safety Caleb Downs expressed his belief that Smith and Tate have the potential to become the best wide receiver duo in college football history. He stated, “You can lowkey give the nod to Jeremiah and Carnell. If they keep playing at the level they are…”
Current Season Performance
This season, Smith leads the Buckeyes with 55 receptions, totaling 725 yards and scoring nine touchdowns. Carnell Tate is not far behind, boasting 39 catches for 711 yards and seven touchdowns. Their contributions have propelled Ohio State to an impressive 8-0 record and the top position in the AP Top 25.
Comparison with Jefferson and Chase
- During the 2019 season, Justin Chase recorded:
- 84 receptions
- 1,780 yards
- 20 touchdowns
- Justin Jefferson’s stats included:
- 111 catches
- 1,540 yards
- 18 touchdowns
Both Chase and Jefferson are now NFL stars, earning multiple Pro Bowl selections. Jefferson was named NFL Offensive Player of the Year in 2022, while Chase clinched the receiving triple crown in 2024.
Future Outlook for Smith and Tate
Caleb Downs acknowledges that while Smith and Tate have not yet reached the performance level of Chase and Jefferson, there is potential for them to make a significant impact. He noted, “Not yet. I’m saying though, at the end of the season, if they stay on the track they are, it’s a real conversation.”
Jeremiah Smith, a sophomore, has at least one more year in college before entering the NFL draft. Carnell Tate, now a junior, is a highly regarded prospect and ranks as the No. 2 receiver in the latest draft big board from Brent Sobleski of Bleacher Report.
Conclusion
As the season progresses, all eyes will be on Jeremiah Smith and Carnell Tate as they strive to establish themselves among the greatest college football wide receiver duos. Their journey, filled with promise, is just beginning.



