BBC Considered Releasing Top Gear Host for Diversity in Line-Up

The iconic trio of Jeremy Clarkson, James May, and Richard Hammond on the British television show Top Gear attracted an astonishing 350 million viewers at its height. Their dynamic chemistry and entertaining presentations made the show a global phenomenon. However, recent revelations from co-creator Andy Wilman’s new book, “Mr. Wilman’s Motoring Adventure,” indicate that the BBC faced internal pressure regarding the show’s diversity.
BBC’s Concerns Over Presenter Diversity
According to Wilman, senior executives at the BBC contemplated replacing one of the show’s presenters due to concerns about having three middle-aged white men. The BBC executives highlighted the show’s appeal to younger viewers from diverse backgrounds, suggesting a shift in the presenter line-up to include a young black or Asian host. Wilman expressed his disbelief at the idea, questioning why they would change a successful formula that resonated with audiences.
Formation of the Top Gear Team
The revival of Top Gear in the early 2000s marked the beginning of an iconic journey. In late 2000, Clarkson and Wilman conceptualized a new format for the show. Though they initially struggled to find co-presenters, both May and Hammond eventually joined the team under unusual circumstances. Hammond’s audition stood out due to his humor about his career woes, ultimately ensuring his spot.
Challenges Behind the Scenes
- The BBC initially toyed with the idea of firing Hammond and fellow original presenter Jason Dawe after the show’s first series.
- The network’s preference was to introduce “chalk and cheese” dynamics, contrasting with Clarkson and Hammond’s established rapport.
- Wilman recounts a series of controversies that led to investigations into the show’s culture and practices.
After the show’s reputation suffered due to a racially insensitive joke and other missteps, the relationship between Top Gear and the BBC became strained. While the show’s subsequent internal investigations found no wrongdoings, they highlighted a breakdown in communication and trust.
Final Years of Top Gear
The show’s eventual decline culminated in a controversial altercation involving Clarkson in March 2015, which led to his suspension and subsequent departure from the BBC. This event marked the beginning of the end for the original Top Gear trio, who later transitioned to Amazon to create the successful series The Grand Tour.
Reflections on Top Gear’s Legacy
Despite its ups and downs, Top Gear left a lasting impact on television. The combination of Clarkson, May, and Hammond created a unique format that captivated audiences worldwide. Wilman’s insights provide a fascinating look at the challenges faced behind the scenes and the evolving expectations of diversity in entertainment.
The book, “Mr. Wilman’s Motoring Adventure,” is set to be released on November 6, shedding light on the unforgettable moments and mishaps that shaped the Top Gear legacy.


