Teoscar Hernandez’s stellar performance in the 2023 MLB season highlighted both the successes and missed opportunities for the Detroit Tigers. As a key player for the Los Angeles Dodgers, Hernandez finished the season with remarkable statistics that included a .271 batting average, a .339 on-base percentage, and an impressive .840 OPS. He also hit a career-high of 33 home runs and earned 4.3 Wins Above Replacement (WAR), contributing to his second All-Star selection.
Teoscar Hernandez’s Contract and Decision
Last offseason, Hernandez signed a one-year contract worth $23.5 million with the Dodgers. Despite interest from other teams, including the Tigers, he chose to stay with Los Angeles, partly motivated by his desire to continue winning after securing a championship ring. Reports indicated that other offers, potentially exceeding the three-year, $66 million deal he received from the Dodgers, were on the table, yet Hernandez prioritized winning over maximizing his earnings.
The Tigers’ Struggles and Missed Opportunities
The Tigers faced considerable challenges at the plate, particularly after the All-Star break in 2023. Their postseason performance highlighted a pressing need for additional offensive support. Hernandez could have been that essential piece. His ability to deliver clutch hits would likely have made a significant difference, especially evident from their postseason struggles where the team went 0-for-23 during crucial moments in Game 5 against the Mariners.
Impact of Hernandez’s Performance
- 33 home runs in the 2023 season
- .271 batting average with a .339 on-base percentage
- 2nd All-Star selection
- 4.3 Wins Above Replacement (WAR)
Hernandez’s performance in critical postseason games for the Dodgers highlighted the difference a clutch player can make. His contributions changed the dynamic for Los Angeles, underscoring what could have been for the Tigers.
Future Considerations for the Tigers
This offseason, the Tigers face important decisions about strengthening their roster. The need for additional offensive firepower is clear. Although they pursued other options, such as Alex Bregman, their efforts to secure talented free agents have often been hampered by location and market factors.
Looking ahead, the Tigers must reconsider their approach to free agency. If a proven playoff performer like Hernandez becomes available, they may need to adopt a more aggressive bidding strategy. Manager AJ Hinch’s ability to optimize player roles, even with imperfect fits, adds flexibility to their lineup. The Tigers’ near-misses in previous seasons should serve as a reminder that strategic acquisitions can shift the team’s trajectory in future postseason pursuits.
