The Carolina Panthers are facing a clear decision at quarterback following a disappointing performance by Andy Dalton against the Buffalo Bills. Last season, the Panthers contemplated whether Bryce Young should reclaim his starting role after Dalton took over. However, Dalton’s poor display in their recent game has eliminated any uncertainty about the team’s starting quarterback.
Dalton’s Struggles Against the Bills
In their latest outing on October 26, 2025, Dalton’s performance was criticized heavily. ESPN analyst Louis Riddick expressed his concerns on social media, stating that Dalton appeared as if he had never played in the NFL before. His tweet read, “Andy Dalton legit looks like he has never played. Ever.”
Hall of Fame tight end Shannon Sharpe echoed Riddick’s sentiments, labeling Dalton’s performance as “atrocious.” Sharpe pointed out that Dalton has not performed well since his time in Cincinnati and highlighted his struggles during this particular game.
Performance Highlights
- Dalton completed a few deep passes to rookie wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan.
- He struggled significantly outside of these plays, leading to numerous sacks.
- Dalton ended the game with seven sacks, one interception on a screen pass, and a lost fumble.
- He recorded fewer than 180 passing yards and failed to throw a touchdown.
His overall performance has prompted questions about his future in the league. The Panthers re-signed Dalton during the offseason, but it’s evident he has not met the team’s expectations as a starting quarterback.
Looking Ahead to Next Week
The Panthers hope to have Bryce Young return against the Green Bay Packers next week. Head coach Dave Canales mentioned the possibility of Young practicing as early as Wednesday. If Young cannot participate, third-string quarterback Hendon Hooker may be given the opportunity to start.
Starting Hooker, despite the challenges of facing a formidable Packers team, would provide valuable experience. In contrast, continuing to start Dalton would serve little purpose for the Panthers at this stage.
In summary, the Panthers are gearing up for a pivotal moment in their season. The choices they make at quarterback will significantly impact their trajectory as they move forward.
