Recent comments about Toronto Blue Jays players have sparked controversy among MLB fans. During a World Series preview, ESPN’s Bill Plaschke and several colleagues made disparaging remarks regarding catcher Alejandro Kirk and first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Body-Shaming Criticism of Blue Jays Players
Alejandro Kirk, a 26-year-old catcher, has made significant contributions to the Blue Jays since his MLB debut in 2020. Notably, he has been an All-Star in 2022 and 2025 and won a Silver Slugger Award in 2022. He has also been acknowledged as a Gold Glove finalist this season.
Despite these accomplishments, Plaschke initially claimed ignorance of Kirk’s identity, stating, “I don’t know anybody who could name you their lineup.” His co-hosts reminded him that Kirk is the current catcher, but Plaschke remarked, “He’s not exactly a hulking presence.” This comment drew immediate backlash from fans.
Further Remarks and Responses
The situation escalated when Jack Harris, a Dodgers beat writer, chimed in with a body-shaming comment about Kirk, implying he is “hulking in some sense.” Plaschke continued his critique of the team, saying it bores him, even as he acknowledged Guerrero Jr., who boasts an impressive postseason batting average of .442 with six home runs.
Plaschke concluded with a somewhat positive note regarding Guerrero, saying, “I like fatty Vladdy,” eliciting laughter from his fellow presenters. The overall tone of the discussion has angered many Blue Jays fans, who expressed their discontent across social media platforms, including X (formerly Twitter).
Impact on Blue Jays Fans and Team Morale
These comments have become motivational fodder for the Blue Jays as they prepare for their World Series matchup against the reigning champion Dodgers. Many fans see it as an opportunity for Kirk and Guerrero Jr. to prove their worth on a grand stage.
- Alejandro Kirk: MLB debut in 2020, All-Star in 2022 and 2025, Silver Slugger in 2022, Gold Glove finalist.
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr.: Hitting .442 with six home runs in postseason.
- Controversial Remarks: Made by Bill Plaschke and Jack Harris regarding player physiques and team performance.
As anticipation builds for the World Series, the Blue Jays will certainly be looking for a strong performance that defies the negative characterizations made by ESPN commentators.
