This Week 8 presents fantasy football owners with a critical decision regarding wide receivers Keenan Allen and DeVonta Smith. Both players have enjoyed impressive performances recently, making the choice even more challenging.
Keenan Allen’s Performance Against the Vikings
Keenan Allen is currently ranked as WR24 for this week. He has climbed to WR7 for the 2025 season in PPR leagues, averaging over nine targets per game. In his most recent outing against the Colts, he had his best game of the season, gathering 11 catches for 119 yards.
Despite facing a formidable opponent in the Minnesota Vikings, who have allowed the fourth-fewest fantasy points per game to wide receivers, Allen’s involvement in the Chargers’ offense keeps him relevant. His high target count indicates that he remains a vital part of the game plan, although he is competing with players like Ladd McConkey Jr. and Quentin Johnston for targets.
DeVonta Smith’s Matchup with the Giants
On the other hand, DeVonta Smith holds the WR16 ranking this week and is positioned as WR11 for the season in PPR leagues. Coming off an outstanding performance against the Vikings, Smith caught nine passes for 183 yards and one touchdown. He has averaged nearly nine targets per game over his past three outings, indicating a strong presence in the Eagles’ passing game.
The Giants’ defense has struggled against wide receivers, allowing the third-most fantasy points and second-most receiving yards per game. However, it’s noteworthy that Smith performed modestly in their previous meeting two weeks ago, recording just four catches for 49 yards.
Making the Decision
The matchup for Smith appears more favorable compared to Allen’s challenging scenario. While both players are capable of strong performances, Smith seems to have the advantage due to the Giants’ defensive weaknesses.
- Keenan Allen:
- Current WR ranking: WR24
- Season WR ranking: WR7
- Average targets per game: 9+
- Last week: 11 catches, 119 yards
- Tough matchup against Vikings
- DeVonta Smith:
- Current WR ranking: WR16
- Season WR ranking: WR11
- Average targets over last three games: 9
- Last week: 9 catches, 183 yards, 1 touchdown
- Favorable matchup against Giants
In conclusion, while both players show promise, DeVonta Smith is better positioned for success in Week 8. His matchup against the Giants and higher target share make him the preferred choice over Keenan Allen this week.
