The Seattle Mariners experienced a significant moment in their quest for the World Series after winning Game 5 of the American League Championship Series last Friday. However, their aspirations were crushed when they faced a defeat in Game 7 on Monday. The outcome, particularly the events of the seventh inning, will likely remain a focal point of discussion as the team heads into the offseason.
Mariners’ Roster Concerns Following ALCS Game 7 Loss
As the Mariners look to upgrade their roster for the 2025 season, they face critical decisions regarding several players. While retaining some talent may not be challenging due to limited free agency, it’s essential to identify players who are likely to depart. Here are four Mariners who may not return for the 2026 season after the heartbreak of their ALCS Game 7 loss.
1. Eugenio Suárez – Third Base
- Age: 34
- Previous Team: Arizona Diamondbacks
- Notable Achievement: Game-winning grand slam in ALCS Game 5
Eugenio Suárez’s potential departure would be a tough blow for the Mariners. Even though his return to Seattle this summer didn’t meet initial expectations, he showed his value during the playoffs. However, Seattle’s GM Jerry Dipoto has not indicated a desire to retain him, making it likely Suárez will explore other options in free agency.
2. Jorge Polanco – Second Base/DH
- Age: 32
- 2026 Player Option: $6 million
- Regular Season Performance: Career-best 134 OPS+
Jorge Polanco, who activated his player option, is anticipated to decline it based on his recent performance. With multiple impactful hits in October, his strong postseason could attract lucrative multi-year offers on the open market. The Mariners might opt to focus on younger talent, like Cole Young, instead.
3. Mitch Garver – Catcher
- Age: 34
- Mutual Option for 2026: $12 million
- Playoff Highlight: SAC fly in ALDS Game 5
Mitch Garver’s future with the Mariners appears uncertain, as the team is likely to buy him out for $1 million instead of exercising his mutual option. With a disappointing offensive showing in Seattle, the Mariners may look to promote Harry Ford as a backup catcher, who has demonstrated considerable promise in the minors.
4. Caleb Ferguson – Left-Handed Pitcher
- Age: 29
- Recent Performance: Struggled in August and September
- Future Status: Free agent
Caleb Ferguson’s role in the Mariners’ bullpen did not live up to expectations. After a rocky performance late in the season and during the playoffs, it seems unlikely he will return. Seattle is expected to explore various options to bolster their left-handed relief pitching.
As the Mariners analyze their roster following the disappointing loss in the ALCS Game 7, they face crucial decisions about the future of these players. Keeping their championship aspirations alive will require strategic moves in the coming months.
