Federal Inmate Fatally Shot Amid Rare Florida Prison Gunfire

An Illinois man, Dwayne Tottleben, was fatally shot while serving time at a federal prison in Florida. This incident occurred at the U.S. Penitentiary Coleman I, a high-security facility located northwest of Orlando, on October 10, 2023. His family and officials confirmed the shooting, which is considered rare given that prison guards are typically not armed.
Details of the Incident
Despite the usual protocol for the federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) to communicate inmate deaths, no specific information was provided regarding Tottleben’s case. His family has expressed frustration over the lack of transparency. According to officials from the local medical examiner’s office, Tottleben was indeed shot, but details surrounding the shooting remain unclear.
Tottleben’s close friend and next of kin, Donna Ford, received a phone call from the prison informing her of his death. They had spoken just hours earlier, and she described him as being in good spirits during their last conversation.
Background of Dwayne Tottleben
At the time of his death, Tottleben, 33, was serving a 15-year sentence for possession of methamphetamine with intent to distribute. He had previously been involved in a legal dispute with law enforcement stemming from a police shooting in October 2020, which may have impacted his mental well-being. Tottleben’s family members noted a troubled upbringing, which they believe contributed to his life choices.
- Date of incident: October 10, 2023
- Location: U.S. Penitentiary Coleman I, Florida
- Age of the deceased: 33
- Sentence: 15 years for possession of methamphetamine
Responses and Future Actions
The prison has placed itself on “enhanced modified operations,” limiting visitation until further notice. Former BOP officer Joe Rojas noted that gunfire incidents in federal prisons are rare, with alternative non-lethal measures typically employed in confrontations. Tottleben’s family has started a GoFundMe campaign to raise funds for legal assistance as they seek answers surrounding his death.
Attorney Robert J. Slama, representing Tottleben’s family, plans to pursue an independent medical examination. He emphasized the need for full accountability from the prison regarding this tragic incident.
Final Thoughts
The shooting of Dwayne Tottleben raises significant concerns about the safety of inmates and the effectiveness of prison policies. As investigations continue, many are left questioning how such violence can occur within the confines of a high-security facility.