The San Francisco Giants are on the verge of appointing Tony Vitello as their new manager, according to reports from various sources. This decision would mark a significant departure from tradition, as Vitello, currently the head coach at the University of Tennessee, lacks any professional baseball coaching experience. However, he is celebrated for his impressive track record in NCAA baseball.
Transitioning to the Giants
While a strong candidate for the Giants’ managerial position, Vitello has noted that no decision has been finalized. He addressed the speculation after a recent scrimmage with the Volunteers, affirming that discussions are ongoing. His transformative role at Tennessee since taking over in 2017 has significantly elevated the program’s status, culminating in a College World Series championship in 2024.
Nick Hundley Withdraws
Before Vitello emerged as the top candidate, former Giants catcher Nick Hundley was considered the frontrunner. However, he has since withdrawn from consideration for personal reasons related to his family. Hundley, who resides in San Diego, is also being pursued by the Padres following the retirement of their former manager, Mike Shildt.
- Hundley is 42 years old and has two young daughters.
- He previously declined an interview opportunity for the Giants in the past due to family commitments.
Vitello’s Success at Tennessee
During his tenure at Tennessee, Vitello has propelled the baseball program from one of the weakest in the Southeastern Conference to a formidable contender. Under his leadership:
- The Volunteers have reached five NCAA super regionals.
- They have participated in the College World Series three times since 2017.
His success has not gone unnoticed; he became the highest-paid college baseball coach in history with a contract worth $3 million annually through 2029. This salary is comparable to what many Major League Baseball managers earn.
Impact on the Giants’ Coaching Staff
If hired, Vitello would have a role in selecting his coaching staff. Currently, two positions are vacant: bench coach and third base coach, as Ryan Christenson and Matt Williams will not return. Recommendations for additional coaching staff from Melvin’s time will also be considered.
The Giants’ previous manager, Bob Melvin, was dismissed less than a month ago after two seasons marked by mediocre performance. In 2025, the team finished with an 81-81 record and missed the postseason, while in 2024, they concluded the season at 80-82.
Looking Ahead
President of baseball operations Buster Posey is looking for a manager who exhibits a meticulous attention to detail and a passion for player development. With the potential hire of Vitello, the Giants could be taking a bold step towards rejuvenating their franchise.
Whether Vitello decides to make the leap to Major League Baseball remains to be seen, but the Giants are certainly keen on making a significant change in their management approach.
