A California judge has dismissed Drake’s defamation lawsuit against Universal Music Group (UMG) concerning Kendrick Lamar’s diss track titled “Not Like Us.” Judge Jeannette Vargas ruled that the lyrics, which allege that Drake and his associates are “certified paedophiles,” represent a “nonactionable opinion” and therefore cannot be deemed defamatory.
Details of the Case
Drake, whose real name is Aubrey Graham, filed the lawsuit in January, claiming that UMG permitted the release and promotion of the song, which he argues spreads a “false and malicious narrative.” The ruling came after extensive legal deliberation regarding the nature of artistic expression within the hip-hop genre.
Background of the Song
Released in May 2024, “Not Like Us” is part of a series of tracks that highlight an ongoing rivalry between Drake and Lamar. This song has achieved significant success, becoming one of Lamar’s biggest hits, winning five Grammy Awards, and gaining notoriety during his Super Bowl half-time performance in February.
Judge’s Rationale
- The judge described the conflict between the two artists as “the most infamous rap battle in the genre’s history.”
- She emphasized that the context of the lyrics—often characterized by incendiary language and hyperbole—would lead reasonable listeners not to interpret the assertions as factual.
- Conversely, she noted that both rappers have used similar provocative language against each other in the past.
In her 38-page ruling, Judge Vargas pointed out that Drake had previously suggested Lamar make similar allegations in his own lyrics, exemplifying the mutual exchange of barbs prevalent in rap battles.
Reactions to the Ruling
In response to the dismissal, a UMG representative stated that the lawsuit was an “affront to all artists” and expressed satisfaction with the court’s decision while looking forward to future collaborations with Drake.
Drake’s spokesperson confirmed intentions to appeal against the ruling, stating, “we look forward to the Court of Appeals reviewing it.” As of now, Kendrick Lamar has not made any public comments regarding the court’s decision.
