Top MLB DFS Picks and Strategy on FanDuel for Saturday, May 16

As the MLB moves into the weekend, Saturday’s main slate at FanDuel, featuring eight games set to kick off at 7:10 p.m. EDT, presents intriguing dynamics for daily fantasy sports (DFS) enthusiasts. Featured prominently is White Sox starter Davis Martin at an eyebrow-raising $10,300, marking a potential shift in strategy as he emerges as the slate’s top-priced pitcher. However, caution is warranted. Rival ace Jacob deGrom at $10,100 is likely to attract a majority of the roster spots due to his established pedigree. The Mariners, listed as the slate’s biggest favorite at -166, coupled with the Rangers (-148) and Braves (-142), should frame the key pitching choices for DFS players this weekend. With the Giants-A’s matchup boasting the highest total at 9.5 runs and four other games listed at 8.5, it’s evident that this slate may lean toward lower-scoring endeavors, opening the door for strategic pitching selections.
Pitching Picks and Strategy: The $10,300 Dilemma
At this juncture, it’s essential to unpack the implications of Davis Martin’s pricing. It signals a divergence from traditional fantasy norms, forcing players to weigh risk against potential reward. While some may opt for the safe bet on deGrom, focusing on cheaper, high-upside options becomes crucial.
- Bryce Elder, ATL vs. BOS ($9,700): Elder’s consistency shines, allowing no more than three runs in all nine starts. Boston’s struggling offense, which ranks last against right-handed pitchers, could be ripe for exploitation.
- Logan Gilbert, SEA vs. SD ($8,500): With likely the best matchup against a battered San Diego lineup, Gilbert brings solid numbers and an opportunity for a 3x return on investment.
- Logan Henderson, MIL at MIN ($7,800): Henderson’s strong strikeout rate paired with Minnesota’s high strikeout propensity presents an enticing narrative for bargain hunters.
Top Offensive Targets: Stackability and Value Plays
For offense, the A’s present an affordable stacking option, capitalizing on favorable prices that provide breathing room under salary constraints. Players like Nick Kurtz ($4,000) offer a solid starting platform.
- A’s Targets: Treasures await in the A’s lineup against Giants starter Trevor McDonald, who struggles with left-handed bats. Consider stacking around Kurtz.
- Yankee Conundrum: The matchup against Huascar Brazoban means Aaron Judge ($4,500) and Ben Rice ($4,200) might see fewer at-bats against left-handed pitching.
- Bargain Bats: Even though the Rangers have been inconsistent, targeting cheap left-handed hitters against Kai-Wei Teng can yield returns, with Corey Seager ($2,900) being a potential yet risky inclusion.
Before vs. After: Stakeholder Impact Analysis
| Stakeholder | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Davis Martin | Underpriced & Unproven | Overpriced as Slate’s Top Arm |
| Jacob deGrom | Everyday Ace | Potentially Overlooked with Heavy Roster |
| DFS Players | Predictable Strategies | Rethink Pitching and Stacking Approach |
Localized Echoes: The Broader Market Context
The implications of this slate reach far beyond individual players. As FanDuel and competitors like DraftKings vie for DFS supremacy in the U.S., Canadian, UK, and Australian markets, strategies are evolving. Economically, the steady growth of domestic sports betting is pushing platforms to refine their offerings, particularly regarding DFS options. This dynamic creates a ripple effect, shaping how player performances influence betting trends in respective markets.
Projected Outcomes: A Look Ahead
Expect the following developments in the coming weeks as the MLB season unfolds:
- Market Adjustments: Pricing strategies could shift dramatically based on player performances leading to potential influxes of value plays.
- Injury Management: The health of key players, especially regarding teams like the Yankees, will heavily impact lineup constructions.
- Pitching Strategies: Continued exploration into non-traditional high-priced options like Martin may redefine roster building as more data becomes available.

