On October 4, 2025, the Toronto Blue Jays celebrated a significant victory over the New York Yankees in the American League Division Series. The game, held at Rogers Centre, marked the Jays’ first postseason triumph in nine years. The team won decisively with a score of 10-1, taking a 1-0 series lead.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Shines in October
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. was the star of the night. He opened the scoring with a solo home run in the first inning, electrifying the home crowd. This marked Guerrero’s first playoff long ball and his first multi-hit postseason game, helping elevate Toronto’s spirits after multiple postseason disappointments.
Before this game, Guerrero had struggled in the playoffs, with a .136 batting average across six games. His previous postseason performances lacked memorable moments, but this time he delivered when it mattered most.
Blue Jays’ Pitching Dominance
The pitching strategy for the Blue Jays proved effective. Louis Varland, acquired at the trade deadline, showcased his skills by relieving Kevin Gausman, who pitched 5 2/3 innings, allowing just one earned run. Varland struck out Yankees slugger Giancarlo Stanton to escape a bases-loaded jam, exemplifying the impact of the Jays’ focus on acquiring high-velocity pitchers.
Manager John Schneider emphasized the need for varied pitching strategies to create swing-and-miss opportunities, a goal that clearly paid off in Game 1.
Yankees’ Struggles at the Plate
The Yankees faced significant challenges, with Aaron Judge failing to capitalize on a bases-loaded situation in the sixth inning. His strikeout came after a full count, illustrating the pressure that postseason play can exert on even the top performers. Judge is still seeking his breakthrough playoff moment, having had a lackluster showing in previous games.
Defensive Lapses and Bullpen Issues
The Yankees’ bullpen also faltered, starting with Luke Weaver, who walked a batter and allowed two singles shortly after entering the game. Fernando Cruz followed but struggled as well, allowing a double that extended Toronto’s lead. The Yankees ultimately surrendered ten runs, their first postseason game allowing such a number since 2018 against the Boston Red Sox.
Gil’s Early Exit
The Yankees’ starting pitcher, Luis Gil, did not perform as expected, giving up a home run to Guerrero and another to Alejandro Kirk. Gil’s pitching speed was down compared to previous outings, indicating a lack of effectiveness that forced the Yankees to turn to their bullpen early in the game.
Kirk Continues Power Surge
Alejandro Kirk continued his impressive form from the regular season into the playoffs. Following a strong finish to the season, he hit two home runs in Game 1, further solidifying his crucial role in the Blue Jays lineup.
What’s Next for Both Teams?
With this emphatic win, the Blue Jays look to maintain their momentum. Meanwhile, the Yankees must regroup and address their bullpen questions as they prepare for the rest of the series. This pivotal first game sets the stage for what promises to be an exciting playoff battle.
