A federal magistrate judge has ruled that New York State is illegally operating a segment of the Thruway on Seneca Nation land. This significant decision was made by Judge Michael Roemer, who issued a report this week stating that the easement arranged with the Seneca Nation in the 1950s breaches federal law.
Judge Roemer’s Findings
The court’s findings indicate that any transfer of tribal land requires federal government approval. Approximately three miles of the Thruway runs through Seneca Territory in Western New York. If a federal district court accepts the report, New York State will be required to negotiate a valid easement.
Seneca Nation’s Claims
The Seneca Nation asserts it is entitled to toll revenue generated from this Thruway section. Estimates suggest that the total revenue could amount to around $4 billion. However, this financial request was not included in Judge Roemer’s report.
State Response
The governor’s office has not provided any comments regarding the ongoing litigation. The state’s position will likely evolve as the case progresses through the judicial system.
Key Details:
- Judge: Michael Roemer
- Location: Seneca Territory, Western New York
- Length of Thruway in Question: Approximately 3 miles
- Toll Revenue Claim: Estimated at $4 billion
- Status: Ongoing litigation, awaiting federal district court’s decision
This ruling highlights ongoing disputes regarding tribal sovereignty and land rights in New York. As the situation develops, it may have lasting implications for the relationship between state authorities and the Seneca Nation.
