In a tense matchup on September 30, 2025, the New York Yankees faced the Boston Red Sox in Game 1 of the American League Wild Card Series. The Yankees lost 3-1, prompting scrutiny on manager Aaron Boone’s decisions, particularly regarding the pitching rotation.
Boone’s Controversial Decision
Starting pitcher Max Fried delivered an impressive performance, giving up no runs over 6⅓ innings. Boone initially planned to replace Fried after six innings but decided to let him continue when Fried induced a double play with 99 pitches thrown. Fried ultimately completed one more out before Boone replaced him with Luke Weaver.
Fried’s Performance
- Max Fried pitched 102 total pitches.
- He allowed four hits and recorded 63 strikes.
- Anthony Volpe’s solo home run gave the Yankees an early 1-0 lead.
Fried expressed confidence in his stamina, stating he felt capable of continuing. Boone, however, justified his decision by highlighting that Fried faced significant pressure in the later innings. “His command was not as good those final few,” Boone remarked.
Yankees’ Bullpen Struggles
After Boone opted for Weaver, the bullpen faltered. Weaver walked his first batter and subsequently allowed a double and a two-run single from Masataka Yoshida, who was pinch-hitting. The bullpen’s struggles were evident as they failed to protect the late lead, leading to a loss.
Weaver’s Challenges
- Weaver has struggled since returning from injury, with a 5.31 ERA in his last 40 appearances.
- He faced Ceddanne Rafaela, walking him after an 11-pitch at-bat.
- Weaver expressed disappointment in his performance, noting, “I just got to be better.”
Offensive Missed Opportunities
The Yankees had a chance to tie the game in the ninth inning after loading the bases with no outs. However, they failed to score, an outcome that disappointed the team. Paul Goldschmidt acknowledged the missed opportunity, stating, “One hit there and we tie the game.”
Looking Ahead
Boone’s decisions during the game have been met with criticism, reminiscent of previous playoff decisions. The Yankees now must regroup as they prepare for Game 2, hoping to convert chances into runs and bolster their bullpen performance.
This game highlighted the ongoing challenges faced by the Yankees, particularly concerning their bullpen, which ranked 23rd in Major League Baseball with an ERA of 4.37. As the series continues, all eyes will be on how Boone manages his pitching staff moving forward.
