Emerald Fennell’s latest film, a modern adaptation of “Wuthering Heights,” opened to polarized opinions. Set to be released on Friday, this version emphasizes style over substance, inviting viewers to experience its visual presentation more than the story itself. This film adaptation focuses solely on the first half of Emily Brontë’s gothic novel, omitting crucial plotlines and deeper character development.
Adaptation Choices and Artistic Direction
Fennell’s adaptation showcases a stylized representation rather than a faithful retelling of Brontë’s work. The film reduces the narrative complexity, offering a 50% decrease in plot and character depth. However, it compensates for this with increased emphasis on explicit scenes and visual allure.
Fennell has made a bold statement regarding her interpretation, using quotation marks in the title to signal a divergence from traditional adaptations. She acknowledged her work’s subjectivity, stating, “I can’t say I’m making Wuthering Heights, it’s not possible.” This approach indicates that the film prioritizes cinematic styles over strict adherence to the original story.
Visual Aesthetics and Costume Design
Working with acclaimed costume designer Jacqueline Durran, Fennell created numerous outfits that reflect a mid-century influence. For instance, lead character Cathy, portrayed by Margot Robbie, has 50 distinct costumes. The costumes draw parallels with iconic films, including “Gone with the Wind” and “Donkey Skin,” showcasing a relaxed interpretation of period accuracy.
- Cathy’s white tulle frock with velvet appliqué resembles a 1939 design by Merle Oberon.
- Robbie’s blood-red, velvet hooded cape echoes earlier cinematic styles.
- Jewelry worn in this adaptation recalls designs from past classics, connecting eras visually.
In a press interaction, Fennell expressed her rejection of strict period accuracy, suggesting the film should resonate emotionally rather than historically. Durran echoed this sentiment, emphasizing an instinctive and emotional rationale behind their choices.
Audience Reception and Historical Context
Early reviews of the 1939 Hollywood version by William Wyler recognized its emotional depth, an aspect Fennell likely aspires to replicate. However, her adaptation’s lighter narrative may affect how audiences connect with the thematic essence of Brontë’s original work.
While Fennell’s “Wuthering Heights” captivates visually, its depth may not satisfy purists of the original novel. Ultimately, this cinematic reimagining focuses on visual storytelling, aiming to resonate with film lovers rather than literary enthusiasts.
