Police Shoot and Kill Former NY Officer Armed with Broken Toilet Seat

A tragic incident unfolded at New York-Presbyterian Brooklyn Methodist Hospital when 62-year-old Michael Lynch, a former NYPD officer, was shot and killed by police while armed with a piece of a broken toilet seat. The events occurred shortly before 5:30 p.m. on a Thursday following reports of a violent man inside the hospital.
Details of the Incident
Lynch was admitted to the hospital a day prior, on Wednesday. According to sources, he began cutting himself and threatened others, prompting hospital staff to call the authorities. NYPD Assistant Chief Charlie Minch detailed the chaotic situation during a press conference.
Police Response
- Officers received multiple reports about a violent patient.
- Lynch barricaded himself in a room with an elderly patient and a security guard.
- He threatened to kill both the staff and the individuals trapped with him.
Upon arrival, officers observed blood smeared across the walls and door. Minch stated that police issued numerous verbal commands for Lynch to drop his weapon, yet he refused repeatedly. Officers attempted to enter the room but faced Lynch trying to force the door shut.
Use of Force
Initially, officers deployed a stun gun in an effort to subdue Lynch, but it proved ineffective. He continued advancing toward the officers while brandishing the weapon. After repeated attempts to control the situation, police ultimately shot Lynch, who was pronounced dead at the scene.
Weapon Details
The weapon, identified as a broken toilet seat, raised questions regarding how Lynch obtained it. Police later confirmed the lack of a criminal record for Lynch and mentioned that he had resigned from the NYPD in the 1990s, although the reasons were not disclosed.
Implications for Law Enforcement
Assistant Chief Minch emphasized the dangers faced by police officers daily. He stated that moments like this highlight the unpredictable and hazardous situations encountered by law enforcement tasked with ensuring public safety.
This incident serves as a stark reminder of the complexities surrounding mental health crises and the potential threats they pose in public spaces.




