A contentious dispute in Tulpehocken Township, Berks County, revolves around a proposed farm ordinance that remains undisclosed to residents. Over the past months, local inhabitants, including farmer John Schueller, have spent significant amounts advocating for access to this ordinance, which impacts local agritourism and short-term rental regulations.
Background of the Dispute
The Tulpehocken Township supervisors initiated discussions on this ordinance in February 2025. Although these discussions took place in public forums, residents were not allowed to review the actual drafts. Schueller expressed his concerns, stating that not having access to these documents hampers meaningful participation in community matters.
Legal Proceedings
- Schueller, after several denied requests for draft copies, filed a Right-to-Know request in June 2025.
- The state Office of Open Records has ruled twice that the township must release the drafts to Schueller.
- Despite these rulings, the township has appealed the decisions in Berks County Court, a rare move in such cases.
Financial Implications
The monetary costs involved are substantial. Schueller estimates he and fellow residents have collectively spent about $5,000, with projections of an additional $2,000 to $3,000. On the other hand, the township has incurred costs exceeding $3,776 in legal fees to resist releasing the ordinance drafts.
Community Reaction
This ongoing dispute has drawn criticism from transparency advocates, including media law counsel Melissa Melewsky. She emphasized the importance of public access to such documents, as they greatly influence the community. “It’s egregious that public resources are being used to deny public access,” Melewsky remarked.
Current Status and Future Steps
As of now, the original draft of the ordinance has been replaced by a revised version, which has been presented with fewer restrictions. However, Schueller continues his legal battle for the earlier drafts, advocating for transparency as a fundamental right. He believes that allowing the township’s actions to go unchecked undermines public participation.
Importance of Civic Engagement
Schueller has lived in Tulpehocken Township for nearly his entire life and emphasizes the necessity of citizen involvement in local governance. He asserts that every resident should have access to public discussions that directly affect their lives. “We have a Right-To-Know procedure designed to enable residents to obtain information essential for community participation,” he stated.
The ongoing legal and civic battle highlights a broader concern regarding transparency in local governance, the implications of which resonate throughout the community. Tulpehocken Township residents remain attentive, hoping for a resolution that upholds their right to knowledge and involvement.
