The Hobbit trilogy, directed by Peter Jackson, is an adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s 1937 novel. This cinematic venture was released in three parts: The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012), The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013), and The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies (2014). While the films captured the essence of Tolkien’s world, their endings diverged notably from the original text.
The Darker Ending of The Hobbit Trilogy Explained
The film series introduces a darker tone, particularly in its conclusion. In the final installment, Bilbo Baggins faces significant changes compared to Tolkien’s lighter ending. The film adaptation sees Bilbo involved in intense conflicts, leading to the deaths of pivotal characters like Thorin Oakenshield, Fili, and Kili. Following these events, Bilbo returns to Hobbiton, but his homecoming is tinged with foreboding.
Bilbo’s Return and the Warning
Upon returning to Bag-End, Bilbo is shocked to find his possessions being sold off due to his presumed death. After a heartfelt farewell with Gandalf, the wizard warns him against the misuse of magic rings. Gandalf’s caution reflects his understanding of the One Ring’s corruptive power, a fact Bilbo is still oblivious to at this point.
Key Differences from the Book
Tolkien’s original narrative offers a more optimistic conclusion. In the book, Bilbo declines much of Smaug’s treasure but retains enough to live comfortably. He returns home as a wealthy hobbit, embracing a life filled with adventures as he documents his journey. In contrast, the film presents a more troubled Bilbo who struggles with deceit and the burden of the One Ring.
- Film Conclusion: Bilbo’s lie about the Ring and his struggle with greed set a darker tone.
- Book Conclusion: Bilbo returns home content, living a peaceful life free from darker temptations.
Character Development and Impact
The trilogy alters Bilbo’s character arc, shifting from a humble, honest hobbit to one entangled in webs of deceit. His decision to lie about the Ring undermines his growth, contrasting sharply with Tolkien’s portrayal of Bilbo as brave and forthright. This change may leave an unsettling legacy for Frodo, who later faces the consequences of Bilbo’s choices.
Conclusion
In summary, The Hobbit Trilogy’s darker ending significantly deviates from Tolkien’s original narrative. The adaptations introduce a complex Bilbo, whose moral struggles foreshadow the challenges of future generations. This divergence enriches the story while simultaneously complicating Bilbo’s character, resulting in a narrative that blends adventure with moral ambiguity.
