The NFL has seen its fair share of quarterback contracts that backfired, primarily impacting team dynamics and finances. As teams focus on rebuilding their rosters, several contracts stand out for their detrimental effects. Here’s a closer look at some of the most contentious quarterback contracts in recent NFL history, along with lessons learned from each situation.
Top Takeaways from the Worst NFL Quarterback Contracts in Recent History
Tua Tagovailoa – Miami Dolphins
Tua Tagovailoa’s struggles have become a topic of discussion as the Dolphins’ playoff hopes faded in 2025. His contract is a significant talking point, especially considering his inconsistency and inability to perform in cold weather. Through 14 games this season, he recorded:
- 2,660 passing yards
- 20 touchdowns
- 15 interceptions
- 88.5 passer rating
These stats reflect a decline in performance, raising questions about his long-term viability as a starting quarterback. Miami has learned the importance of reliability in both health and performance in adverse conditions.
Kirk Cousins – Atlanta Falcons
Kirk Cousins signed a four-year, $180 million deal with the Atlanta Falcons before the 2024 season. Despite the substantial investment, Cousins battled injuries and a lack of communication from the management. In his tenure, he achieved:
- 4,726 passing yards
- 24 touchdowns
- 19 interceptions
- 9-10 record
The franchise made a critical error by investing in an aging player recovering from a serious injury while simultaneously drafting a quarterback.
Deshaun Watson – Cleveland Browns
Deshaun Watson’s five-year, fully guaranteed $230 million contract with the Cleveland Browns raised eyebrows and remains a hot topic. Since signing, he has only played in 19 games, achieving:
- 9-10 record as a starter
Watson’s ongoing legal issues and subsequent injuries have made this deal particularly risky for the franchise. The lesson here emphasizes the need for careful consideration before making a player with pending allegations among the highest-paid in the league.
Daniel Jones – New York Giants
Daniel Jones signed a four-year, $160 million contract with the New York Giants in 2023 but struggled to meet expectations. After 16 games, his performance included:
- 10 touchdowns
- 13 interceptions
His departure from the team highlights the importance of supporting key players and maintaining a balanced roster. The Giants missed out on retaining star running back Saquon Barkley, further complicating their situation.
Conclusion
These contracts exemplify the risks associated with signing quarterbacks without adequately assessing their current condition and future potential. Teams must weigh financial commitments against performance reliability and consider broader team dynamics to avoid repeating past mistakes.
