Cubs BCB After Dark: Choose Michael King or Tatsuya Imai?

BCB After Dark brings together baseball enthusiasts for discussions, music, movies, and more. Recently, the focus is on two pitching options for the Chicago Cubs: Michael King and Tatsuya Imai. Fans are weighing their preferences as the team seeks to enhance its roster for the upcoming season.
Cubs Pitching Dilemma: Michael King vs. Tatsuya Imai
The Chicago Cubs are reportedly interested in adding significant pitching talent this offseason. Two key players under consideration are Michael King, a right-hander, and Tatsuya Imai, a promising Japanese import.
Michael King: Pros and Cons
Michael King, 30, had a notable 2024 season, recording 173.2 innings in 31 games with a strong 2.95 ERA. His statistics reflect him as a solid number-two starter, featuring an impressive sinker and changeup. However, injury concerns linger, as he made only 15 starts last season.
- 2024 Performance: 13 wins, 9 losses, 2.95 ERA
- Injury History: Limited effectiveness after returning from injury with a 6.11 ERA in his final five starts.
- Contract Outlook: Estimated deal around $20 to $25 million for four years, but a qualifying offer means the Cubs would lose a draft pick.
Tatsuya Imai: The Newcomer
Tatsuya Imai, 28, presents a different profile. Known for his diverse pitching skill set, he boasts a fastball velocity of 93 to 97 mph. Unlike King, Imai does not come with a qualifying offer, making him potentially less expensive in terms of draft implications.
- Pitch Arsenal: Four-pitch mix, including a unique splitter/changeup combination.
- Health Record: Healthy for the past three seasons, but previous injuries raise concerns.
- Contract Estimates: Potential deal ranging from $80 million to $160 million, likely four years at about $120 million.
Considering the Risks
Both players come with their share of risks. King’s recent injury raises questions about his long-term viability, while Imai’s adaptation to Major League Baseball could pose challenges, especially given differences in competition level and ball specifications.
The Cubs face a crucial decision as they evaluate which pitcher may be a better fit for their needs. Ultimately, this decision could also impact their budget for other potential signings.
As fans await the Cubs’ final decision, the discourse around Michael King versus Tatsuya Imai highlights the excitement and uncertainty of offseason baseball.



