Allegations have emerged regarding academic intimidation that has led to a significant legal dispute involving Sheffield Hallam University and Professor Laura Murphy. Central to this issue is a claim that her research, which focuses on forced labor in China, faced external threats from individuals purportedly associated with China’s National Security Service.
Background of the Allegations
Internal documents obtained by Professor Murphy through a Subject Access Request reveal troubling communications. These documents indicate that university staff in China received direct threats demanding the cessation of Professor Murphy’s research activities. Following the university’s decision to halt the final phase of the research, it appears that relations improved, alleviating the threat to staff wellbeing.
University’s Response and Legal Action
In early 2023, Professor Murphy was informed by Sheffield Hallam University that she could not continue her research related to China. This prompted her to initiate legal action, citing infringements on her academic freedom. Subsequently, the university reversed its decision and expressed apologies to her.
Reasons Behind the University’s Original Decision
A spokesperson for Sheffield Hallam highlighted various factors that influenced the initial decision to suspend Murphy’s research. Key points include:
- The inability to secure necessary professional indemnity insurance.
- A defamation lawsuit pending against the university involving a Chinese firm linked to Murphy’s earlier report.
Current Status of the Research
After a comprehensive review, Sheffield Hallam University has approved Professor Murphy’s latest research initiatives. The university expressed its commitment to supporting her work and promoting academic freedom in adherence to legal guidelines.
Commitment to Academic Freedom
In its statement, the university emphasized that its initial decision was not influenced by commercial interests in China, noting that the country does not represent a significant international student market for the institution. Moving forward, Sheffield Hallam has reiterated its dedication to upholding freedom of speech and academic inquiry.
