The Pittsburgh Pirates faced significant challenges during the 2025 MLB season, leading to a managerial change and heightened expectations for improvement. Following a disappointing performance, the team parted ways with manager Derek Shelton early in the season. His bench coach, Don Kelly, was appointed as the new manager, taking the reins for the 2026 season and beyond.
Despite speculation regarding General Manager Ben Cherington’s future, he is confirmed to return for the 2026 season. The focus now shifts to whether the Pirates can finally reverse their fortunes.
Pittsburgh Pirates’ Offseason Strategy: A Comprehensive Outlook
The Pirates enter the offseason with several critical financial commitments and pressing needs to enhance their roster. Here’s an overview:
- Total 2026 Contract Commitments: $30.5 Million
- Total Long-Term Commitments: $130.5 Million through 2030
Performance Overview
The team’s performance in 2025 was overwhelmingly disappointing, particularly on offense. The Pirates ranked last in the majors in scoring, tallying only 583 runs. This figure is nearly 300 runs below the league-leading New York Yankees, who scored 849 runs.
- Home Runs: 117 (ranking 30th, 31 behind the 29th place Cardinals)
- Batting Average: 28th in MLB
- On-Base Percentage: 23rd in MLB
- Slugging Percentage: Last in MLB
Future Goals and Challenges
The primary objective for the Pirates’ management will be to drastically improve their offensive output. The team has received positive recognition for its young pitching talent, highlighted by likely NL Cy Young candidate Paul Skenes. However, the disparity between their pitching success and offensive struggles is stark and must be addressed decisively.
With team owner Bob Nutting emphasizing a need for “urgency,” the pressure is on Cherington to enhance the offensive lineup. While the Pirates are expected to be active in acquiring new players, there might also be opportunities to trade veteran players. Such trades would target acquiring young hitters who are ready to contribute at the major league level.
This offseason presents a pivotal opportunity for the Pirates to reshape their roster, elevate their performance, and build towards a brighter future. The direction they take will significantly influence their success in upcoming seasons.
