Legendary pitcher Randy Johnson has voiced his concerns over Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh’s defensive techniques as the Blue Jays pursue the American League Championship Series (ALCS) title. His critique focuses on Raleigh’s one-knee catching stance, a method that has gained popularity among catchers in Major League Baseball (MLB).
Randy Johnson’s Critique of Cal Raleigh
Johnson highlights a notable trend in baseball: analysts rarely scrutinize the controversial one-knee stance. His tweet raised questions about its effectiveness: “Announcers won’t say anything about the 1 knee catching, will they? How’s it working out for Seattle?” This inquiry ties into broader discussions on the merits of the catching technique.
Analysis of Catching Techniques
A July 2025 MLB.com analysis noted that catchers using the one-knee stance had a higher fielding value compared to those relying on the traditional two-knee method. However, the one-knee approach accounts for 96% of pitches caught in the majors, which complicates the statistical advantages by merely reflecting its prevalence rather than its quality.
Cal Raleigh’s Offensive Impact
Despite questions surrounding his defensive mechanics, Raleigh has made significant contributions offensively this season. The 27-year-old catcher belted 60 home runs and drove in 125 runs, showcasing his power-hitting capability. With a .247 batting average and a .359 on-base percentage, Raleigh has proven valuable to Seattle’s lineup.
Blue Jays’ ALCS Aspirations
The Blue Jays are keen on securing their position in the World Series as they face the Seattle Mariners. Following his impressive performance, Max Scherzer tied the playoff series at two games each. Toronto is eager for a Game 5 pitching rematch between Kevin Gausman and Bryce Miller.
Bo Bichette’s Potential Return
Another crucial storyline for the Blue Jays is the potential return of shortstop Bo Bichette. Injured on September 6 against the Yankees, his absence has been felt during the ALCS. Bichette was having a standout season, targeting the American League hits title with 181 hits in 139 games and boasting a .311 batting average.
- Key Statistics for Bo Bichette:
- 181 hits in 139 games
- .311 batting average
- Tied for second in MLB hits, just three behind Bobby Witt Jr.
Recovery Status
Though Bichette’s rehabilitation is progressing, he remains sidelined as he awaits full medical clearance. Reports indicate that he has been ramping up his physical activity but is not yet ready for game action. Should Toronto advance past Seattle, Bichette’s return could significantly bolster their lineup for a potential World Series matchup.
As the ALCS unfolds, Johnson’s observations about catchers’ techniques and the Blue Jays’ potential personnel changes will add intriguing layers to a high-stakes playoff narrative.
