In a candid media appearance, San Jose Sharks owner Hasso Plattner criticized former player Erik Karlsson, labeling him as not a “team-friendly” player. This remark was made while Plattner discussed the team’s rebuilding strategy, which began in 2022 and led to Karlsson’s trade to the Pittsburgh Penguins in 2023.
Sharks’ Rebuilding Strategy and Karlsson’s Impact
Plattner expressed that the decision to rebuild was a long-standing desire. “(Rebuilding) was actually my wish five years ago,” he stated, reflecting on the challenges the Sharks faced.
- Acquired Karlsson in a blockbuster trade from Ottawa Senators in 2018.
- Western Conference Final appearance in Karlsson’s debut season.
- No playoff appearances in the subsequent four seasons.
- Karlsson’s only healthy season was 2022-23, when he scored 101 points and won the Norris Trophy.
- San Jose ranked 29th in the league during his standout season.
Despite his impressive individual achievements, Plattner noted that Karlsson’s attributes were overshadowed by team dynamics. He remarked, “First, one star is not enough,” emphasizing the collective nature of team sports.
Drafting Issues and Leadership Changes
Plattner attributed part of the Sharks’ rebuilding necessity to poor drafting strategies. He also touched on Doug Wilson’s health problems, which he believed impacted the franchise’s success. Wilson, who served as the general manager for 19 seasons, faced significant health issues that limited his effectiveness.
“You know that he was not well? OK, that says it all,” Plattner said, referring to Wilson’s challenging situation. He acknowledged Wilson’s hockey acumen but criticized his son, Doug Wilson Jr., for his drafting performance during his time as the director of scouting.
- Doug Wilson Jr. served from 2018-19 to 2021-22.
- Only notable draft success under his leadership is William Eklund, 2021’s No. 7 pick.
- Wilson Jr. currently scouts for the Seattle Kraken.
Plattner concluded by expressing regret over not recognizing the drafting shortcomings sooner. His insights into the Sharks’ past reveal the complexity behind player evaluations and management decisions as the franchise navigates through its rebuilding phase.
