The New York Giants made headlines in 2025 when they signed veteran quarterback Russell Wilson for $10.5 million. Unfortunately, this investment has not yielded the expected results, landing Wilson on the list of the worst free-agent signings according to Sports Illustrated’s Gilberto Manzano.
Wilson’s Performance and Impact
Russell Wilson, 37 years old, started three games for the Giants, recording no wins. In those appearances, he struggled significantly, completing less than 60% of his passes in two games and failing to throw a touchdown.
In Week 4, he was replaced by rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart, who had been drafted in the first round. The Giants’ coaching staff believed Wilson’s experience would benefit Dart, allowing him to develop calmly during his rookie season.
Giants’ Struggles in the Red Zone
- Out of 10 red-zone opportunities, the Giants scored just three touchdowns with Wilson as the starter.
- This inefficiency in crucial situations was a primary concern, as high-pressure scenarios are typically where veteran quarterbacks thrive.
Transition to Jaxson Dart
With Dart now at the helm, the Giants secured their first victory of the season against the Chargers. However, Week 5 proved challenging for Dart, who committed three turnovers in a 26-14 loss to the Saints. Despite this setback, the Giants maintain confidence in Dart as the team’s starting quarterback for the remainder of the season.
Future Prospects: Trading Wilson
The Giants face a potential dilemma regarding Wilson’s future. While they may consider trading him, his value has significantly decreased after a series of disappointing performances. Adding to the challenge, the Cincinnati Bengals recently acquired Joe Flacco, further limiting potential trade opportunities.
If the Giants are unable to move Wilson, they might find themselves reconsidering their decision. The money dedicated to his signing could have been allocated more effectively to strengthen other areas of the team.
Conclusion
The Giants are at a pivotal moment in their season. As the team navigates the fallout of Wilson’s underwhelming performance, management will need to make strategic decisions moving forward—especially regarding the future of their investments and roster composition.
