Cinco Paul’s exceptional work for “Schmigadoon!” has earned him the 2026 Tony Award for Best Original Score. The accolade was presented during the 79th Annual Tony Awards held at Radio City Music Hall on June 7, 2026. This win marks Paul’s second victory of the evening, as he also secured the Tony for Best Book of a Musical for the same production.
Cinco Paul’s Remarks on Broadway Musicals
During his acceptance speech, Paul addressed the state of new musicals on Broadway. He emphasized the need for more original works, noting, “There were only six new musicals this season. That is not enough.” Paul encouraged audiences to support new productions, including “Lost Boys” and “Titaníque,” urging everyone to see various musical shows.
About Schmigadoon!
“Schmigadoon!” is adapted from the Apple Original series, which has gained popularity since its debut in 2021. The Broadway adaptation centers on a couple, Josh and Melissa, who stumble into a fantastical world reminiscent of Golden Age musicals, such as “Oklahoma!” and “The Music Man.” The musical incorporates songs from the show’s Grammy-nominated score and introduces new titles, including some that were cut from the series.
Production Details
The Broadway version of “Schmigadoon!” officially opened on April 20, 2026, at the Nederlander Theatre. Directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, the production features a talented cast, including:
- Alex Brightman as Josh Skinner
- Sara Chase as Melissa Gimble
- Max Clayton as Danny Bailey
- Ana Gasteyer as Mildred Layton
- Ann Harada as Florence Menlove
- Brad Oscar as Mayor Menlove
- Isabelle McCalla as Emma Tate
- Maulik Pancholy as The Reverend
- McKenzie Kurtz as Betsy
Many cast members are returning from the musical’s successful premiere in Washington, D.C. in 2025. The ensemble also includes a range of talented performers, with casting directed by Bernard Telsey and Kristian Charbonier.
Design and Production Team
The production features a team of esteemed designers:
- Set Design: Scott Pask
- Costume Design: Linda Cho
- Lighting Design: Donald Holder
- Sound Design: Walter Trarbach
- Hair, Wig, and Makeup Design: Tom Watson
The creative team includes producers such as Lorne Michaels, Caroline Maroney, and Christine Schwarzman. The Tony Awards celebrate excellence in Broadway theatre, with notable figures leading the American Theatre Wing and the Broadway League.
The Future of Schmigadoon!
Although production for the third season of the original series was canceled while in progress, Paul has indicated his ambition to bring all three seasons of “Schmigadoon!” to the stage. The series’ second season debuted in 2023, introducing a new setting with parodies of ’70s musicals.
This recognition at the Tony Awards highlights the ongoing impact of “Schmigadoon!” on the Broadway landscape, paving the way for future original musicals.
