Henry Mantel: Single-Family Zoning Hinders Los Angeles’ Growth

Los Angeles stands on the brink of a crisis that mirrors a dystopian future where basic needs are unmet. The parallel to a food shortage is stark: over a thousand Angelenos succumb to the harsh realities of a housing shortage every year, amid soaring rents and stagnating wages. This plight is inexplicably linked to a zoning law rooted in 1916 that restricts the development of multi-family housing, thereby perpetuating an environment where property value preservation takes precedence over social equity. It is not just a lack of homes—we are witnessing the outright denial of opportunities, with single-family zoning being a primary barrier to progress.
Unpacking Zoning: A Historical Overview
In 1916, lawmakers in Berkeley, California constructed single-family zoning as a racially motivated tool to exclude people of color and immigrants from white neighborhoods. This law quickly spread across the U.S., reaching Los Angeles by the early ‘60s. The consequences were drastic: LA’s zoning capacity decreased from ten million homes in 1960 to just four million by the 1980s. By the 1990s, the housing stock could not keep pace with the surging job market, which saw nearly five job openings for every housing unit added from 2010 to 2015. Fast forward to 2026, and LA has become one of the world’s least affordable cities, with single-family zoning still dominating over 70% of its landscape.
| Stakeholders | Before Single-Family Zoning | After Single-Family Zoning |
|---|---|---|
| Residents | Access to diverse housing options | Limited to single-family homes, rising rents |
| Politicians | Facilitated urban growth | Stymied progress, political backlash |
| Businesses | Stability and growth | High turnover, workforce exodus |
| Environment | Diverse habitats and ecosystems | Increased urban sprawl, resource depletion |
Political Inaction: The Status Quo
The grim realities of LA’s housing crisis are unmistakable, acknowledged repeatedly by local politicians and policies. The Tenant Anti-Harassment Ordinance of 2021 and the LA Rent Stabilization Ordinance of 1979 both highlighted the city’s acute shortage of affordable housing. Yet, in 2025, a majority including Councilmember Katy Yaroslavsky voted against statewide initiatives like Senate Bill 79, designed to increase housing near transit. Just last year, city leaders submitted a housing element that avoided any conversation about amending single-family zoning. This tactical negligence reveals a governmental history steeped in inertia and resistance to change, which directly feeds into the spiraling housing costs.
The Ripple Effect: LA’s Impact on the Broader Market
LA’s housing crisis doesn’t exist in a vacuum; it casts long shadows well beyond its city limits. Across the U.S., high housing costs are increasingly driving young talent to regions offering more affordable living conditions, thereby exacerbating economic inequality. In countries like the UK, Canada, and Australia, urban centers are grappling with similar housing issues, often influenced by outdated zoning laws reminiscent of Los Angeles’. As a result, international real estate markets exhibit rising competition among markets struggling with affordability. Thus, LA’s stagnation threatens to undermine its economic viability on a global scale.
Projected Outcomes: A Glimmer of Hope?
As Los Angeles stares into the abyss of a housing crisis, several developments are poised to unfold in the coming weeks:
- Heightened advocacy for the amendment of single-family zoning regulations, driven by grassroots movements seeking equitable housing solutions.
- Potential shifts in city council dynamics after upcoming elections, possibly introducing representatives willing to challenge the status quo.
- Increased state-level pressure on local governments to adopt more inclusive housing policies, particularly with the backing of Senate Bill 79 and similar legislative initiatives.
The profound truth is that Los Angeles must embrace a future in which building is no longer illegal. Emphasizing the need for diverse housing stock and dismantling antiquated zoning laws, advocates like Henry Mantel, a tenants’ rights attorney and City Council candidate, aim to breathe new life into this sprawling metropolis. It’s a clarion call for all Angelenos: the time to construct a more equitable and accessible Los Angeles is now.




