The Naples City Council is currently reevaluating the future of the annual Cars on 5th event, which has seen a substantial increase in attendance over the years. This year’s event, the 22nd iteration, attracted approximately 39,000 people to Fifth Avenue South, where car enthusiasts showcased over 750 luxury and classic vehicles. Proceeds from the event benefit Habitat for Humanity of Collier County.
Concerns Raised by City Council
During a review meeting on April 1, city council members discussed an after-action report that highlighted several key concerns about the event’s growth. Councilman Bill Kramer stated that many residents voice opposition to large gatherings like Cars on 5th in the city. His phrase, “the juice isn’t worth the squeeze,” suggests that the drawbacks of the event might outweigh its benefits.
- Crowd Safety: The report noted safety concerns due to overcrowding. Emergency vehicle access was highlighted as a significant issue.
- Parking Problems: The event has been criticized for inadequate parking, which has led to conflicts and unauthorized pop-up events.
- City Property Damage: There were reported damages to Cambier Park and surrounding areas.
The Outlook for Future Events
As the council evaluated the feedback, several members indicated that a new venue might be more suitable for the growing event. Suggestions included the Paradise Coast Sports Complex in East Naples and local golf courses, which could accommodate larger crowds without disrupting the city’s main thoroughfare.
Concerns were raised about the economic impact of relocating the event. City Manager Gary Young noted that applying for permits for special events at Cambier Park is currently on hold, leading to uncertainty about future gatherings on Fifth Avenue South.
Understanding the Event’s Impact
The Cars on 5th event has become a significant draw for locals and tourists alike. It transforms Fifth Avenue South into a showcase for high-performance cars, including notable brands such as Ferraris, Lamborghinis, and Porsches. While the organizer, Tom O’Riordan, has expressed deep ties to the city and commitment to maintaining the event’s location, council members question whether it has outgrown its current setting.
Event Success vs. Local Needs
This year, the event managed to raise funds for Habitat for Humanity, although exact figures have not yet been disclosed. Council Member Scott Schultz raised concerns that the benefits of the event appear to favor vendors rather than the local community. He emphasized the need for Naples residents to have their voices heard in decisions regarding events hosted in the city.
Conclusion
As the future of Cars on 5th hangs in the balance, the city council plans to deliberate further on the matter. The decision regarding the event’s permit is expected to be made by May or later. The fate of this iconic event, which has become a staple of Naples’ cultural scene, may ultimately depend on finding a balance between its popularity and the needs of the local community.
