Referee Removed After Controversial Scotland vs France Match
The upcoming Six Nations clash between Scotland and France has stirred considerable anticipation, as it may determine the tournament’s eventual winner. This high-stakes match is set to feature referee Angus Gardner, a seasoned official in the rugby world.
Angus Gardner: An Experienced Referee
Angus Gardner was born in Sydney in 1984. His journey in rugby took an unexpected turn when he was diagnosed with Scheuermann’s Disease, which affected his playing career. At just 15, Gardner began refereeing to remain in the sport he loves.
Rise to Prominence
Gardner transitioned into a full-time professional referee in 2015. His first Test match was officiated in 2011, during the Oceania Cup, between Papua New Guinea and Vanuatu. His Super Rugby debut came in 2012 at Suncorp Stadium.
Key milestones in Gardner’s career include:
- Assistant referee at the 2015 Rugby World Cup
- Referee for the Super Rugby Final in 2018
- Awarded World Rugby Referee of the Year in 2018
- Match official at the 2019 and 2023 Rugby World Cups
In 2023, he was the referee for the semi-final match between Argentina and New Zealand at Stade de France.
Controversies Surrounding Scotland vs France Match
Gardner has had a history of being at the center of controversy. During the 2019 Rugby World Cup in Japan, French captain Guilhem Guirado expressed frustration regarding Gardner’s officiating in a match against Argentina. Guirado claimed the Argentine team engaged too early at scrums, against the new regulations.
Following the match, Guirado stated, “On the first three scrums, they put pressure on us and the referee didn’t say much.”
French prop Jefferson Poirot was more direct, declaring, “We got screwed.” Due to the backlash surrounding his performance in that game, Gardner was removed from the officiating team for the subsequent Argentina-England match, with Ben O’Keeffe taking over his role.
Looking Ahead
The Scotland vs France match promises to be thrilling, with Gardner’s officiating under the spotlight. How he navigates potential challenges during the game could dictate not just the outcome of the match but also his reputation in the rugby community.




