In the competitive landscape of college football, particularly amid the transfer portal frenzy, BYU is taking a distinct approach under head coach Kalani Sitake. With an emphasis on high school recruiting and player development, Sitake is cultivating a program that prioritizes homegrown talent. As the Cougars look ahead to the 2026 season, they are pinning hopes on a promising crop of underclassmen. This article analyzes eight underclassmen poised for breakthrough performances and how their development could redefine BYU’s future.
1. Nusi Taumoepeau – DE/LB
Nusi Taumoepeau’s trajectory as an impact player grew despite a slow season start due to an injury. After debuting against Arizona, he made a significant mark in the Pop-Tarts Bowl against Georgia Tech, showcasing his ability to pressure quarterbacks effectively. His impressive statistics—ranking second in pressure rate and seventh in quarterback pressures—illustrate that when he is on the field, he is a dynamic threat. The potential for Taumoepeau to evolve into a star edge rusher aligns with Sitake’s vision for a high-level defense.
2. Therrian Alexander III – CB
Emerging as a starting cornerback in his sophomore year, Therrian Alexander III displayed raw potential that could elevate him into a star role alongside Evan Johnson. His ability to read plays and react quickly has already drawn comparisons to his teammate. As defensive schemes continue to evolve, Alexander’s progression will be crucial for BYU’s secondary strength in 2026.
3. Tausili Akana – Edge
Having transitioned from Texas to BYU, Tausili Akana is expected to finish refining his skills as he gains more weight and strength. His quickness and technique provide the perfect blend for a standout pass rusher, promising a more significant impact in the coming season. With 12 quarterback pressures under his belt, Akana’s contributions are likely to escalate as he gains confidence and consistency.
4. Cody Hagen – WR
With limited competition returning in the wide receiver corps, Cody Hagen is primed to capitalize on his potential. A four-star recruit, Hagen possesses the ability to leverage his skills to become a pivotal receiving threat. With Bear Bachmeier’s leadership at quarterback, their developing chemistry could yield significant dividends for BYU’s offense.
5. Hunter Clegg – DE
As one of the freshmen with the most substantial snap count last season, Hunter Clegg has earned the trust of his coaching staff. His experience since returning from his mission positions him well for a breakout season as he adjusts to the speed and physical demands of college football.
6. Jojo Phillips – WR
Jojo Phillips showed flashes of brilliance during the Fall Camp but was hampered by injury during the season. His bowl game performance hinted at his potential, and with a full offseason to sync with Bachmeier, he could emerge as a significant contributor in 2026. Phillips’ role could be crucial, particularly given the limited additions to the receiving corps from the transfer portal.
7. Andrew Williams – OL
The offensive line faces a crucial moment as BYU seeks to fill a starting tackle position. Andrew Williams is in the spotlight as a redshirt freshman who has already gained valuable first-team reps. This is a pivotal time for Williams; success could establish him as a foundational piece for the line.
8. Jonathan Kabeya – CB
After an injury setback, Jonathan Kabeya’s return is highly anticipated. His experience adjusting after a redshirt season is expected to pay off, making him a likely candidate for the starting nickel role in 2026. His further development will be vital to countering elite receiving threats in the upcoming season.
Impact Analysis: Stakeholders and Ripple Effects
| Stakeholder | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| BYU Football | Reliant on transfer portal | Homegrown talent flourishing |
| Kalani Sitake | Building roster through transient players | Core players and young talent |
| Bachmeier and Receiving Group | Limited options | Emerging stars among WRs |
| Fan Engagement | Expectations dependent on transfers | Excitement around young prospects |
Projected Outcomes
- Fan enthusiasm will increase as underclassmen demonstrate potential during early practices and games.
- A marked improvement in defensive performance, hinged on the growth of players like Taumoepeau and Akana, can elevate BYU’s competitive positioning.
- Success in integrating young talent will drive recruitment efforts, attracting high school prospects looking for a robust developmental program under Sitake.
In summary, BYU’s strategy of focusing on underclassmen development may yield substantial returns in 2026. The outlined players not only reflect this commitment but also embody the potential for BYU to establish a sustainable cycle of success through homegrown talent.
