The Cincinnati Bengals have found themselves at a critical juncture as the NFL offseason approaches. Whether through a miscalculation of talent evaluation, a conservative ownership style, or a combination of both, the Bengals often sidestep the vigorous free agency activity that shapes other teams. For Cincinnati, managing salary cap constraints seems more daunting than it does for franchises like the New Orleans Saints, who continually navigate financial challenges. Instead of operating in a vacuum, it’s time for the Bengals to reconsider their approach and target proven talent, especially players who’ve demonstrated their capabilities on Championship Sunday.
As they look toward reinvigorating their roster, names like Coby Bryant, Jaylinn Hawkins, and Boye Mafe emerge as compelling targets. Each presents unique opportunities that align with the Bengals’ pressing needs while amplifying their competitive edge. This report dissects the rationality of pursuing these players and assesses the broader implications for Bengals’ strategy in free agency.
Coby Bryant: A Strategic Homecoming
Coby Bryant, the standout safety from the Seattle Seahawks and a Cincinnati native, has positioned himself as a prime target for the Bengals. After transitioning from cornerback to safety, Bryant has thrived in a role that leverages his versatility. With Seattle facing the reality of multiple impending free agents, Bryant’s projected contract—a deal surpassing $45 million over three years—could make him available to the Bengals if they choose to invest strategically.
The Bengals need a solid presence in the secondary, and Bryant embodies that caliber, recording a passer rating against of just 78.2 over the past two seasons with seven interceptions. Not only would his signing be a tactical advantage on the field, but it also carries significant symbolic weight—infusing the organization with a Cincinnati native’s commitment and passion.
Jaylinn Hawkins: A Beacon of Potential
Taking cues from Bryant’s trajectory, the Bengals should also consider Jaylinn Hawkins of the New England Patriots. Hawkins emerged as a pivotal player during his stint with the Patriots, graded as PFF’s seventh-best safety in 2025. His ability to adapt and excel under different schemes positions him as a significant upgrade over the current personnel. At a projected annual value that could start around $9 million, Hawkins could be an affordable yet impactful addition to a Bengals secondary that has struggled with consistency.
With his impressive statistics—ranking high in run defense and pass coverage—Hawkins would enhance the Bengals’ defensive identity while offering room for further development. The willingness to sign players who have weathered adversity reflects a commitment to cultivating a resilient roster.
Boye Mafe: The Underestimated Edge Rusher
Though typically placing emphasis on established stars, the Bengals should also take a chance with players like Boye Mafe. While his two-sack season in 2025 may not seem impressive, delving deeper reveals that Mafe’s role required him to operate within a complex Seahawks defense that harnessed multiple talents. His potential for production remains underappreciated, especially with consistent success in pressuring quarterbacks evidenced by his earlier seasons.
Mafe’s youth combined with his upside in a situation designed for his strengths could prove transformative for the Bengals’ defensive front. With an estimated contract of roughly $36 million over three years, Mafe represents an enticing opportunity to bolster their pass rush without breaking the bank on high-profile names.
Projected Outcomes for Bengals’ Offseason Moves
The Bengals’ strategy heading into this offseason becomes even more significant as the franchise strives to maintain competitiveness in the AFC. Evaluating the potential outcomes of signing Bryant, Hawkins, and Mafe unveils several implications:
- Immediate Defensive Improvement: The arrival of these talents could instantly enhance the Bengals’ defensive metrics, improving coverage capabilities and run defense.
- Local and National Sentiment: Bringing in homegrown talent resonates with fans and could elevate ticket sales and merchandise, cultivating a renewed sense of connection with the community.
- Long-term Culture Shift: Solidifying the locker room with players who’ve experienced adversity could significantly impact the team’s culture, fostering a commitment to excellence that echoes long after the current season.
Summary of Stakeholder Impacts
| Stakeholder | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Bengals | Underdog status, lack of key defensive assets | Strengthened defense, increased local appeal |
| Fans | Frustration with offseason inactivity | Renewed excitement and engagement with the team |
| Ownership | Minimized spending, struggle to gain traction | Potential higher revenue from improved performance and fan engagement |
As the Bengals steer through the offseason, it’s imperative they shift from underbaking their opportunities to taking bold, calculated risks. Focusing on proven players who have thrived in critical moments—like Coby Bryant and Jaylinn Hawkins—could lay the foundation for a future-defining season. The future is in their hands, but it hinges on the willingness to invest in growth, both on and off the field.
