As Jay Hill’s potential move to Michigan gains momentum, the BYU football program prepares for significant changes. Hill, who has served as BYU’s defensive coordinator for three years, has transformed an average defense into a formidable unit, contributing to the team’s 23-4 record and consecutive bowl wins against Power Five teams.
Impact of Jay Hill’s Departure
If Hill departs, it would mark a significant transition for BYU. Under head coach Kalani Sitake, the Cougars have seen improvements in their defensive rankings, placing within the top 25 in multiple categories in the 2025 season. Hill’s skills as a recruiter have also bolstered the defense, attracting talents like safety Faletau Satuala and former Utah tackle Keanu Tanuvasa.
Response from Kalani Sitake
Following BYU’s recent victory over Georgia Tech in the Pop-Tarts Bowl, Sitake commented on Hill’s potential move. He acknowledged that decisions must be made by the staff about their futures. Sitake emphasized the strength of the program, stating, “The program is in a really good spot, because of a lot of people.”
Possible Candidates for Defensive Coordinator
Should Hill leave, several names are circulating as potential replacements:
- Shaun Nua: Currently the defensive line coach at USC, Nua is a former BYU standout with NFL experience.
- Jernaro Gilford: BYU’s cornerbacks coach, Gilford could follow Hill to Michigan or step into the coordinator role.
- Kelly Poppinga: The special teams coordinator, Poppinga has previous experience as co-defensive coordinator at Virginia.
- Lance Anderson: The head coach at Utah Tech, Anderson has a background in building strong defenses but has faced challenges recently.
Kalani Sitake’s Strategic Response
Amid potential staff changes, Sitake expressed confidence in the current team and coaching staff. He mentioned, “I feel really good about what we have going here.” This sentiment underscores his commitment to maintaining the program’s upward trajectory.
Why Michigan is Attractive for Jay Hill
Michigan represents an enticing opportunity for Hill, particularly under head coach Kyle Whittingham’s tenure. The chance to ascend to a head coaching position in the future, coupled with financial incentives that BYU may find challenging to match, are likely factors influencing Hill’s decision. Recent reports suggested that Michigan’s defensive coordinator earned around $2.5 million, a salary far exceeding what BYU could offer.
As the situation develops, both programs will navigate through these pivotal transitions in hopes of maintaining their competitive edge in collegiate football.
