The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel has revealed that Everton deserved a penalty in their 1-0 loss against Arsenal on December 20. The incident occurred during the match at Hill Dickinson Stadium in the 57th minute.
Penalty Controversy Explained
During the match, Everton striker Thierno Barry collided with Arsenal defender William Saliba inside the penalty area. Barry reached the ball first, only to have his boot kicked by Saliba. The panel conducted a vote regarding the on-field decision made by referee Sam Barrott, which concluded with a 3-2 verdict that the referee’s choice not to award a penalty was erroneous.
Video Assistant Referee Evaluation
The panel also determined by a 3-2 vote that the video assistant referee (VAR), Michael Salisbury, should have recommended that the referee review the incident. Three members of the panel described Saliba’s action as a careless kick on Barry, emphasizing the lack of contact with the ball. They characterized the decision as a clear and obvious mistake.
Conversely, two panel members supported the referee’s decision against the penalty, arguing there was insufficient impact and a notable delay in Barry’s reaction.
Manager’s Remarks
Everton manager David Moyes expressed confusion over the decision. He highlighted that similar incidents had been awarded penalties, specifically referencing a spot-kick awarded to Fulham in a match against Nottingham Forest just two days later. The KMI Panel unanimously supported the penalty awarded in that case.
- Moyes stated, “I was half-choking last night when I saw the decision given [to Fulham] and ours wasn’t.”
- He criticized the perception that certain clubs receive favorable treatment in such situations.
Key Panel Composition
The Key Match Incidents Panel consists of five members, including three former players or coaches. Additionally, there is one representative each from the Premier League and Professional Game Match Officials, ensuring a well-rounded analysis of critical game situations.
This incident highlights the ongoing debates over VAR and refereeing decisions in the Premier League, raising questions about fairness and consistency in officiating.
