In a significant legal proceeding, Sarah Pender, an Indiana woman convicted of a double murder, is appealing for mercy in her sentencing modification hearing. The Marion County court listened to her plea, aiming to reduce her original sentence of 110 years. This sentence was imposed after her conviction for the 2000 murders of her roommates, Andrew Cataldi and Tricia Nordman.
Background of the Case
Pender was sentenced in 2002 for her role in the brutal killings, where investigators found the victims shot and their bodies discarded in a dumpster. Pender admitted to being involved but contended that her ex-boyfriend, Richard Hull, was the one who pulled the trigger. Over the years, Pender has claimed that the heavy sentence was unjust.
Sentencing Dynamics
Initially, she received a 45-year sentence for each murder. Pender expressed disbelief at the lengthy term, stating that 110 years felt unfathomable. “I bought the gun. I didn’t run away and report the crime,” Pender said, showing remorse for her actions.
Since her sentencing, Pender has spent a significant portion of her time in solitary confinement, which she argues has contributed to her rehabilitation. In 2008, she attempted to escape from Rockville Correctional Facility, aided by a correctional officer. She was recaptured four months later in Chicago.
Support and Opposition
Recently, some voices have emerged in support of her release. Former Marion County Prosecutor Larry Sells has notably shifted his stance, advocating for Pender’s pardon, calling her original sentence a significant injustice. “It is virtually unprecedented,” remarked Mark Howard, who is assisting in Pender’s case.
Pender’s family supports her appeal, noting plans for her potential reintegration into society if her sentence is modified. Her parents have expressed hope for her future in Arizona, emphasizing a supportive home environment for her rehabilitation.
Victims’ Families Response
Conversely, family members of the victims opposed Pender’s request for sentence modification, highlighting their ongoing pain and loss. Pender expressed her understanding of their grief, stating, “I am so sorry for the terrible loss that you suffered and for the role I played in it.”
Next Steps in the Legal Process
The court has yet to make a ruling regarding her petition. The judge will take 30 days to consider all aspects before reaching a decision. Pender’s father expressed hope for a decision by Christmas, reflecting the family’s optimism amidst uncertainty.
- Case: Double murder of Andrew Cataldi and Tricia Nordman
- Conviction Year: 2002
- Original Sentence: 110 years
- Escape Year: 2008
- Judge’s Decision Timeline: 30 days from hearing
As Pender awaits the outcome, both she and her family are hopeful for a new beginning and the opportunity to rebuild her life outside of prison.
