Cardiff City Football Club is pursuing a significant legal claim against FC Nantes for €120.2 million (£105 million) in the French courts. This lawsuit is a direct result of the tragic death of Argentine striker Emiliano Sala in 2019. The legal proceedings will begin on Monday in Nantes Commercial Court, following an initial hearing that was postponed until December 8.
Background of Emiliano Sala’s Death
Emiliano Sala tragically lost his life in January 2019 when a plane, piloted by David Ibbotson, crashed in the English Channel. Sala was en route to Cardiff City after the club had arranged a transfer from FC Nantes. At the time of his transfer, Cardiff was a Premier League team. Unfortunately, the club faced relegation the same season and has since been demoted to League One.
Legal Arguments and Claims
Cardiff City alleges losses exceeding £100 million due to the impact of Sala’s death on their team performance and financial standing. Their legal representatives plan to argue that the absence of Sala contributed significantly to their relegation, alongside the financial consequences of a transfer fee for a player they could never utilize.
Court Jurisdiction and Legal Proceedings
The case is being pursued in French courts after the Swiss Federal Tribunal determined that the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) did not have jurisdiction over Cardiff’s claims. This complexity highlights the legal challenges involved in this case.
Details of the Case
In April, Cardiff City confirmed their claim of €120.2 million following a thorough analysis conducted by a legal expert. The club’s legal team will also argue that FC Nantes had direct connections with Willie McKay, a football agent who was banned from operating at the time of Sala’s transfer.
Previous Developments
- In February 2024, Cardiff reached a confidential out-of-court settlement with McKay.
- A 2022 inquest jury concluded that Sala died from head and chest injuries exacerbated by carbon monoxide poisoning.
- David Henderson, who arranged the flight, received an 18-month prison sentence for endangering aircraft safety.
Looking Ahead
As the court hearing approaches, Cardiff City emphasizes the importance of accountability in football. They state, “This tragedy… cost Emiliano Sala his life. It is a tragedy that could and should have been avoided.” The club’s legal battle seeks not only justice for Sala but also to enforce higher standards in sports transfers.
Cardiff City expresses confidence in the French legal system as they prepare for the hearing, set for 4 PM French time (3 PM GMT). The ruling is anticipated by spring 2026.
