Attorney: Stepbrother May Testify in Florida Teen’s Cruise Ship Death Case

In a developing situation concerning the death of a Florida teen on a cruise ship, a potential witness may soon testify. The case centers around 18-year-old Anna Kepner, who was found deceased on a Carnival cruise ship earlier this month. Her stepsibling, a 16-year-old boy, is at the heart of ongoing investigations and custody disputes.
Teen’s Possible Testimony in Death Case
During a custody hearing in Brevard County, Florida, attorney Scott Smith discussed the likelihood of the 16-year-old testifying about Kepner’s death. Smith represents Thomas Hudson, the minor’s father, who is embroiled in a custody battle with Shauntel Hudson, the boy’s stepmother.
Details Surrounding the Incident
Kepner’s body was discovered by a housekeeper under a bed on the Carnival Horizon as it neared its return to Miami on November 8. She had been vacationing with her family, including her father, stepmother, and siblings.
- Date of Death: Early November 2023
- Location: Carnival Horizon cruise ship
- Key Individuals:
- Anna Kepner (deceased)
- Thomas Hudson (father)
- Shauntel Hudson (stepmother)
- 16-year-old stepbrother
According to preliminary reports, Kepner had expressed feeling unwell the night before her death. Family members noted her absence at breakfast the following morning, prompting concern.
Legal Complications and Investigations
The legal proceedings are complex, as the 16-year-old is potentially under investigation for involvement in his stepsister’s death. Although law enforcement has not confirmed his status as a suspect in the ongoing FBI investigation, court documents cite him as a person of interest.
During the custody hearing, attorney Millicent Athanason indicated hesitance regarding bringing the minor to the stand, citing concerns about further incrimination. Judge Michelle Studstill noted that a hearing would be necessary before any testimony could be taken from the 16-year-old. It is anticipated that he may assert his Fifth Amendment right to avoid self-incrimination.
Future Hearings
The next hearing is scheduled for December 5, where further developments regarding potential subpoenas will be discussed. Smith has expressed intentions to summon Anna Kepner’s father, Christopher Kepner, to provide more context around the incident.
Investigative Measures
Investigators are actively reviewing surveillance footage from the cruise vessel and analyzing electronic swipe data to ascertain cabin entries. Additionally, they are evaluating cellphone records and conducting interviews with various passengers and crew members as part of their inquiry into the tragic event.




