The NFL trade deadline is approaching, and speculation is swirling around the Chicago Bears and their quarterback situation. Recently, discussions arose regarding whether the Bears should consider replacing Caleb Williams, the 2024 No. 1 overall pick, with backup quarterback Tyson Bagent.
Caleb Williams vs. Tyson Bagent: A Coaching Decision Looms
On the October 22 edition of “The Bill Simmons Podcast,” sports commentator Bill Simmons suggested a significant change. He stated that Bears coach Ben Johnson might bench Caleb Williams in favor of Tyson Bagent by Week 13 or Week 14. According to Simmons, this decision stems from the belief that Williams may be holding back the team’s potential.
“They’re like a playoff team, and Caleb has not been good for them,” Simmons articulated, indicating that Johnson is a strong supporter of Bagent and might opt for him to start. This sentiment has been echoed by others, but not without contention.
Support for Caleb Williams
Contrarily, Scott Bair of Marquee Sports Network firmly disagreed with the notion of replacing Williams. In a mailbag piece dated October 28, Bair asserted that the organization remains committed to their top draft pick. He highlighted Williams’ mobility, arm strength, and potential as key aspects of his game.
Bair emphasized Johnson’s decision to join the Bears, which was influenced by the opportunity to develop Williams as a formidable quarterback. Despite criticism, Bair remains confident in Williams’ capability to thrive in the complex offensive scheme.
Statistical Insights Into Williams’ Performance
In a recent evaluation, Ben Solak from ESPN noted that Williams has shown signs of improvement. By analyzing his Expected Points Added (EPA) per drop back, which stands at 0.03, it becomes evident that Williams is performing relatively well compared to peers like Baker Mayfield.
- Baker Mayfield: 0.05 EPA
- Jayden Daniels: 0.02 EPA
- Jaxson Dart: 0.02 EPA
Solak pointed out that if Williams had performed at this level during his rookie season, Bears fans would likely have been more optimistic about his development. He acknowledged areas for improvement, specifically in accuracy on easier throws and the need to trust his offensive line. Notably, Williams has managed to halve his sack rate from 10% last season to below 5% this year.
Looking Ahead: Bears’ Playoff Aspirations
With the trade deadline on the horizon, the Bears face critical decisions about their quarterback situation. The debate surrounding Caleb Williams and Tyson Bagent could significantly impact the team’s playoff aspirations. As the season progresses, it remains to be seen which direction the Bears will take.
