Pippa Middleton and her husband, James Matthews, face a planning dispute over the closure of a roadway on their estate, Barton Court, in Berkshire. This action has sparked concerns among local residents who maintain that the lane once served as part of a public footpath.
Details of the Road Closure
The entrance to Mill Lane, located on the couple’s estate, was blocked after Matthews purchased the property in 2022. An electric gate was reportedly installed in October 2022, accompanied by signs indicating “no access” and “no entrance.” This development has restricted walkers’ access to an established footpath.
Local Response
The West Berkshire Council designated Mill Lane as a public right of way following an application by the West Berkshire Ramblers. Locals have raised their voices in support of this designation, arguing that the lane is crucial for connecting to the Kintbury footpath. They claim that the closure forces pedestrians onto a “dangerous road” without sufficient safety measures.
- Neil G. Lawrence, a local resident, emphasized the route’s significance, calling it a “key local amenity.”
- Another villager noted that until the gate was installed, there were no barriers restricting access to the path.
Planning Inquiry
A public inquiry, facilitated by the Planning Inspectorate, is scheduled for May 14, 2024, to address this ongoing dispute. The estate manager, Patrick Newnham, has formally objected to the public designation of the lane, asserting that it has been a private route for decades.
The Estate’s Position
In a statement regarding the definitive map modification order, Matthews asserted that the lane does not fulfill the legal criteria to be classified as a footpath. He argued that allowing public access would lead to privacy, security, and practical issues for the family.
Matthews’ case also mentioned that alternative routes are available for walkers in Kintbury, claiming they are more appealing than the now-closed lane. It stated that the lane is merely a surfaced drive with uninspiring views, leading ultimately to a busy roadway.
The community’s reliance on Mill Lane indicates its importance, revealing a divide between private property rights and public access needs. As the inquiry approaches, both sides prepare to present their arguments, with significant implications for local walkers and Middleton’s estate.
