Marshals Review: CBS’ Yellowstone Spinoff Blends Prestige Procedural with Dutton Flair

Nearly two years after the conclusion of Paramount Network’s “Yellowstone,” CBS reinvigorates the Dutton legacy with its latest spinoff, “Marshals.” This crime procedural reintroduces Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton, who embarks on a new chapter in his life as a member of the U.S. Marshals.
The Dilemma of Kayce Dutton
Kayce’s transition from a cattle rancher to a fugitive hunter introduces a complex inner conflict. He must navigate his duties as a Marshal while also safeguarding the Broken Rock Reservation, to which he is fiercely loyal due to his marriage. This duality sets up a compelling narrative as he strives to balance these conflicting worlds.
A Blend of Genres
Helmed by Spencer Hudnut, known for “S.E.A.L. Team,” “Marshals” successfully intertwines the essence of “Yellowstone” with classic procedural elements. The challenge lies in maintaining the rich narrative fabric of Taylor Sheridan’s storytelling while appealing to a broader audience on network television. The initial three episodes, released prior to the show’s premiere on March 1, exhibit this balance effectively.
Visuals and Storytelling
With a captivating score and cinematic quality, “Marshals” often blurs the lines between a traditional network procedural and a high-end drama. However, moments arise that remind viewers of its procedural roots, such as weekly case introductions and tactical meetings that reinforce typical genre tropes.
Character Dynamics and Development
New viewers need not worry about prior knowledge of “Yellowstone.” The series does an excellent job of summarizing Kayce’s backstory. Yet, longtime fans will appreciate the subtleties and character references that enrich the narrative. Kayce’s interactions with Thomas Rainwater, played by returning actor Gil Birmingham, resonate with added depth from established history.
- Cal: Played by Logan Marshall-Green, he recruits Kayce, presenting him as a beleaguered individual seeking redemption.
- Andrea: Portrayed by Ash Santos, she is motivated by a quest for vengeance for her deceased father.
- Miles: Tatanka Means takes on the role of the inexperienced team member grappling with his dual identity.
- Belle: Arielle Kebbel, known for her work in “9-1-1,” plays a fearless undercover agent with significant family legacies.
Thematic Depth
The theme of “new beginnings,” encapsulated by the premiere title “Piya Wiconi,” resonates throughout the series. While Kayce grapples with the complexities of fatherhood and personal demons, each team member carries their burdens, driven by a relentless quest for resolution.
The show encapsulates a refreshing approach to the crime procedural genre. With enough depth to satisfy “Yellowstone” enthusiasts and the traditional procedural audience, “Marshals” stands as a unique addition to CBS’s lineup. The combination of visual appeal and heartfelt storytelling ensures that viewers will be engaged and entertained throughout each episode.




