Michigan’s Attorney General Dana Nessel recently declared that the Republican-led House’s decision to cut $645 million in state spending is unconstitutional. The cuts were made last month using a provision of state law, which Nessel argues violates the Michigan Constitution’s separation of powers.
Michigan Spending Cuts Overview
The unilateral cuts were enacted by the House Appropriations Committee under GOP leadership. They intended to lapse funds previously approved by both the governor and the full Legislature, targeting various programs and projects.
Details of the Cuts
- $159 million for the Make It In Michigan Competitiveness Fund
- $18.5 million for the RxKids program aiding new mothers
- Funding for the Holocaust Memorial Center in Farmington Hills
- $56,600 for wigs for children undergoing cancer treatment
- $2.5 million for a pilot study on school zone traffic cameras
- $1.3 million for the Office of Global Michigan
- $1.9 million in grants to local symphony orchestras
- $800,000 for a fire truck in Hamtramck
Legal Arguments and Implications
Nessel’s opinion, issued in a 29-page document, states that the reviewed law violates constitutional provisions governing how legislation is enacted. The Attorney General emphasized that allowing one legislative committee to override spending decisions undermines the dedicated roles of the executive and legislative branches.
House Speaker Matt Hall criticized Nessel’s interpretation, labeling it “absurd and incorrect.” He asserted that he plans to take the issue to court. Hall maintained that the cuts were necessary to manage government spending effectively.
Reactions from Lawmakers
Republican legislators defended their actions. House Appropriations Chair Ann Bollin argued that her committee acted legally and responsibly in overseeing taxpayer funds.
Meanwhile, Democratic leaders expressed support for Nessel’s opinion. Senate Appropriations Chair Sarah Anthony referred to the opinion as a critical lifeline for affected organizations and local governments.
Next Steps for Michigan House Republicans
While House Republicans prepare for potential legal challenges, the State Budget Office announced its agreement with Nessel’s findings. Steps to restore previously cut funding have begun, aiming to resume financial support to affected groups soon.
