The Ottawa Senators recently concluded a projected five-year period of “unparalleled success.” This prediction was made under former owner Eugene Melnyk and was anticipated to span from 2021 to 2025. Unfortunately, this time frame ended without fulfilling the promise of competitive achievement, marked by just one playoff appearance.
Background on the Prediction
In February 2019, during a corporate event in Toronto, Melnyk assured sponsors that the Senators were poised for a strong rebuild. He emphasized the importance of the team’s partners and community contributions totaling over $105 million. Melnyk’s remarks indicated confidence that the Senators would not only rebuild but spend close to the NHL salary cap each year to assemble a competitive roster.
Key Transactions and Roster Decisions
Tragically, Melnyk’s upbeat projection began to falter soon after it was made. In March 2019, the Senators traded away top scorers Mark Stone, Matt Duchene, and Ryan Dzingel. Despite a commitment to invest in young talent, the team struggled to fill gaps with effective veterans.
Over the years, some contracts aimed at building the foundation included:
- Thomas Chabot: Long-term contract in the summer of 2019
- Colin White: Signed simultaneously with Chabot
- Matt Murray: Acquired in a significant deal following advice from General Manager Pierre Dorion
- Drake Batherson: Six-year contract in 2021
- Brady Tkachuk: Seven-year contract following Batherson
Melnyk’s Passing and Continuing Commitment
Melnyk passed away in March 2022, just over a year into the five-year promise. His untimely death led to new ownership taking over the Senators and continuing the pattern of significant spending. In the summer of 2022, notable contracts included:
- Claude Giroux: Three-year, $19.5 million contract
- Alex DeBrincat: Acquired from the Chicago Blackhawks
- Josh Norris: Eight-year contract
- Tim Stützle: Eight-year deal at $8.35 million AAV
- Artem Zub: Four-year contract
These decisions raised questions about Melnyk’s initial intent and whether he would have supported such moves. His management style had established a culture that made it challenging to attract top executive talent.
Looking Ahead for Senators Fans
The five-year window touted by Melnyk is now closed, and only one playoff appearance remains to show for it. Fans experienced a rollercoaster of emotions from hope to skepticism throughout this period. As this chapter comes to an end, it highlights the persistent longing for what could have been.
Currently, the focus shifts to the future. El-Balad recognizes the Senators’ fandom, which clings to a desire for sustained success—and perhaps that success is simply on a delay.
