The Detroit Lions are currently exploring options for a new offensive coordinator. Among potential candidates is Mike McCarthy, a Super Bowl-winning coach with extensive experience in NFL offenses. McCarthy’s impressive resume includes notably high success rates during his tenures with the Green Bay Packers and Dallas Cowboys. This pursuit raises questions about whether he would be a good fit for Detroit.
Mike McCarthy’s Coaching Credentials
Mike McCarthy has an outstanding history as a head coach, achieving:
- 185 career wins
- Eight division titles
- 12 winning seasons in 18 years
His offenses have frequently excelled, finishing among the top NFL scoring teams:
- Ranked first four times
- In the top five nine times
- In the top 10 eleven times
Quarterback Development
A significant strength of McCarthy is his quarterback development. This could appeal to the Lions, who are invested in signal-caller Jared Goff. McCarthy found success in developing quarterbacks like Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers.
Brett Favre’s Resurgence
Under McCarthy’s guidance, Brett Favre rejuvenated his career. In 2007, Favre achieved exceptional efficiency, bouncing back from a challenging 2005 season with 29 interceptions.
Aaron Rodgers’ Impressive Tenure
McCarthy coached Aaron Rodgers for 11 seasons, leading him to two MVP awards in 2011 and 2014. During this period, Rodgers amassed:
- 337 touchdown passes
- 79 interceptions
- 42,615 passing yards
Rodgers finished with a 100-57-1 record, showcasing unparalleled performance as an NFL passer.
Recent Experience with the Cowboys
From 2020 to 2024, McCarthy was the head coach of the Dallas Cowboys. During this time, he witnessed Dak Prescott achieve impressive numbers, specifically in 2021 and 2023:
- At least 36 touchdown passes
- Fewer than 10 interceptions
- Completion rates over 68.8%
In 2023, Prescott finished as a runner-up for the MVP award, reinforcing McCarthy’s offensive prowess.
Considerations for the Lions
Despite his credentials, some experts question McCarthy’s fit as Detroit’s offensive coordinator. There are concerns about his innovation and ability to elevate the Lions’ offense, reminiscent of what former coordinator Ben Johnson achieved. Furthermore, McCarthy may prefer a head coaching role rather than settle for an offensive coordinator position.
Current Lions general manager Brad Holmes may not prioritize McCarthy for the offensive coordinator vacancy. Analysts suggest there’s only a 5-10% chance he becomes Detroit’s offensive play-caller in 2026.
While Mike McCarthy brings invaluable experience and respect, the Lions might find other candidates more aligned with their vision for the team’s offensive future.
