The Fair Lawn Police Department has recently resolved a cold case from 1965, relating to the murder of 18-year-old Alys Eberhardt. Richard Cottingham, a convicted serial killer, has confessed to this tragic crime. Eberhardt’s body was discovered in her family home, showing signs of being both stabbed and bludgeoned.
Confession from a Serial Killer
Richard Cottingham, who has been incarcerated since 1981, admitted to murdering Eberhardt during interviews in late 2022. His health has been declining, prompting these confessions to law enforcement. The details he provided about the murder scene were previously unknown to the public.
Investigation Reopened
The investigation into Eberhardt’s death was reopened in 2021 under the direction of former Chief Glen Cauwels. Detectives Eric Eleshewich and Brian Rypkema led the effort to connect Cottingham to this case.
Community Response
Chief Joseph Dawicki expressed pride in solving Fair Lawn’s only outstanding homicide. He stated, “While we cannot bring Alys back, I am hopeful her family can find some peace knowing her killer confessed and is behind bars.”
Family’s Reaction
The confession has brought relief to Eberhardt’s family. Michael Smith, her nephew, shared, “Our family has waited since 1965 for the truth.” He highlighted the emotional weight of receiving closure just in time for the holidays.
Cottingham’s Current Status
Cottingham is currently serving three life sentences in South Woods State Prison and has additional murder detainers. Authorities have confirmed that no new charges will be filed in this case.
- Name of Victim: Alys Eberhardt
- Murder Year: 1965
- Location: Fair Lawn, New Jersey
- Confessed Killer: Richard Cottingham
- Incarceration Start Year: 1981
This significant confession provides closure for a case that remained unresolved for nearly six decades. The community can finally move forward, albeit with the memory of a young life tragically cut short.
